CRMar 6
Before You Hand Over the Wheel: Evaluating LLMs for Security Incident AnalysisSourov Jajodia, Madeena Sultana, Suryadipta Majumdar et al.
Security incident analysis (SIA) poses a major challenge for security operations centers, which must manage overwhelming alert volumes, large and diverse data sources, complex toolchains, and limited analyst expertise. These difficulties intensify because incidents evolve dynamically and require multi-step, multifaceted reasoning. Although organizations are eager to adopt Large Language Models (LLMs) to support SIA, the absence of rigorous benchmarking creates significant risks for assessing their effectiveness and guiding design decisions. Benchmarking is further complicated by: (i) the lack of an LLM-ready dataset covering a wide spectrum of SIA tasks; (ii) the continual emergence of new tasks reflecting the diversity of analyst responsibilities; and (iii) the rapid release of new LLMs that must be incorporated into evaluations. In this paper, we address these challenges by introducing SIABENCH, an agentic evaluation framework for security incident analysis. First, we construct a first-of-its-kind dataset comprising two major SIA task categories: (i) deep analysis workflows for security incidents (25 scenarios) and (ii) alert-triage tasks (135 scenarios). Second, we implement an agent capable of autonomously performing a broad spectrum of SIA tasks (including network and memory forensics, malware analysis across binary/code/PDF formats, phishing email and kit analysis, log analysis, and false-alert detection). Third, we benchmark 11 major LLMs (spanning both open- and closed-weight models) on these tasks, with extensibility to support emerging models and newly added analysis scenarios.
CRSep 23, 2025
Identifying and Addressing User-level Security Concerns in Smart Homes Using "Smaller" LLMsHafijul Hoque Chowdhury, Riad Ahmed Anonto, Sourov Jajodia et al.
With the rapid growth of smart home IoT devices, users are increasingly exposed to various security risks, as evident from recent studies. While seeking answers to know more on those security concerns, users are mostly left with their own discretion while going through various sources, such as online blogs and technical manuals, which may render higher complexity to regular users trying to extract the necessary information. This requirement does not go along with the common mindsets of smart home users and hence threatens the security of smart homes furthermore. In this paper, we aim to identify and address the major user-level security concerns in smart homes. Specifically, we develop a novel dataset of Q&A from public forums, capturing practical security challenges faced by smart home users. We extract major security concerns in smart homes from our dataset by leveraging the Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA). We fine-tune relatively "smaller" transformer models, such as T5 and Flan-T5, on this dataset to build a QA system tailored for smart home security. Unlike larger models like GPT and Gemini, which are powerful but often resource hungry and require data sharing, smaller models are more feasible for deployment in resource-constrained or privacy-sensitive environments like smart homes. The dataset is manually curated and supplemented with synthetic data to explore its potential impact on model performance. This approach significantly improves the system's ability to deliver accurate and relevant answers, helping users address common security concerns with smart home IoT devices. Our experiments on real-world user concerns show that our work improves the performance of the base models.