Sarah Goodwin

Harriet Mason, Dianne Cook, Sarah Goodwin et al.

Better representation of the uncertainty in a data visualisation is a focus of recent research activity. A problem with the current literature is that there is a lack of clarity about the definition of uncertainty and what it means to represent it in a plot. This confusion results in a significant amount of conflicting results in the literature, especially in experiments that assess the effectiveness of different uncertainty representations. In this review, we summarise the current literature, provide workable definitions, and illustrate these definitions with examples. In doing so, we ask what it really takes to achieve transparency in statistical graphics. It is hoped that it will be useful for guiding new graphics methodology and experimental research.

Songhai Fan, Simon Angus, Tim Dwyer et al.

Exponential growth in the quantity of digital news, social media, and other textual sources makes it difficult for humans to keep up with rapidly evolving narratives about world events. Various visualisation techniques have been touted to help people to understand such discourse by exposing relationships between texts (such as news articles) as topics and themes evolve over time. Arguably, the understandability of such visualisations hinges on the assumption that people will be able to easily interpret the relationships in such visual network structures. To test this assumption, we begin by defining an abstract model of time-dependent text visualisation based on directed graph structures. From this model we distill motifs that capture the set of possible ways that texts can be linked across changes in time. We also develop a controlled synthetic text generation methodology that leverages the power of modern LLMs to create fictional, yet structured sets of time-dependent texts that fit each of our patterns. Therefore, we create a clean user study environment (n=30) for participants to identify patterns that best represent a given set of synthetic articles. We find that it is a challenging task for the user to identify and recover the predefined motif. We analyse qualitative data to map an unexpectedly rich variety of user rationales when divergences from expected interpretation occur. A deeper analysis also points to unexpected complexities inherent in the formation of synthetic datasets with LLMs that undermine the study control in some cases. Furthermore, analysis of individual decision-making in our study hints at a future where text discourse visualisation may need to dispense with a one-size-fits-all approach and, instead, should be more adaptable to the specific user who is exploring the visualisation in front of them.

Yalong Yang, Tim Dwyer, Kim Marriott et al.

We introduce Tilt Map, a novel interaction technique for intuitively transitioning between 2D and 3D map visualisations in immersive environments. Our focus is visualising data associated with areal features on maps, for example, population density by state. Tilt Map transitions from 2D choropleth maps to 3D prism maps to 2D bar charts to overcome the limitations of each. Our paper includes two user studies. The first study compares subjects' task performance interpreting population density data using 2D choropleth maps and 3D prism maps in virtual reality (VR). We observed greater task accuracy with prism maps, but faster response times with choropleth maps. The complementarity of these views inspired our hybrid Tilt Map design. Our second study compares Tilt Map to: a side-by-side arrangement of the various views; and interactive toggling between views. The results indicate benefits for Tilt Map in user preference; and accuracy (versus side-by-side) and time (versus toggle).

Yalong Yang, Tim Dwyer, Sarah Goodwin et al.

Showing flows of people and resources between multiple geographic locations is a challenging visualisation problem. We conducted two quantitative user studies to evaluate different visual representations for such dense many-to-many flows. In our first study we compared a bundled node-link flow map representation and OD Maps [37] with a new visualisation we call MapTrix. Like OD Maps, MapTrix overcomes the clutter associated with a traditional flow map while providing geographic embedding that is missing in standard OD matrix representations. We found that OD Maps and MapTrix had similar performance while bundled node-link flow map representations did not scale at all well. Our second study compared participant performance with OD Maps and MapTrix on larger data sets. Again performance was remarkably similar.

Yalong Yang, Sarah Goodwin

In this paper, we present our analysis of five expert interviews, each from a different application domain. Such analysis is crucial to understanding the real-world scenarios of analysing geographically-embedded flow data. The results of our analysis show that similar high-level tasks were conducted in different domains. To better describe the targets of these tasks, we proposed three flow-targets for analysing geographically-embedded flow data: single flow, total flow and regional flow.

Ethan Kerzner, Sarah Goodwin, Jason Dykes et al.

Applied visualization researchers often work closely with domain collaborators to explore new and useful applications of visualization. The early stages of collaborations are typically time consuming for all stakeholders as researchers piece together an understanding of domain challenges from disparate discussions and meetings. A number of recent projects, however, report on the use of creative visualization-opportunities (CVO) workshops to accelerate the early stages of applied work, eliciting a wealth of requirements in a few days of focused work. Yet, there is no established guidance for how to use such workshops effectively. In this paper, we present the results of a 2-year collaboration in which we analyzed the use of 17 workshops in 10 visualization contexts. Its primary contribution is a framework for CVO workshops that: 1) identifies a process model for using workshops; 2) describes a structure of what happens within effective workshops; 3) recommends 25 actionable guidelines for future workshops; and 4) presents an example workshop and workshop methods. The creation of this framework exemplifies the use of critical reflection to learn about visualization in practice from diverse studies and experience.