Thomas Hain

Rosanna Milner, Md Asif Jalal, Raymond W. M. Ng et al.

For speech emotion datasets, it has been difficult to acquire large quantities of reliable data and acted emotions may be over the top compared to less expressive emotions displayed in everyday life. Lately, larger datasets with natural emotions have been created. Instead of ignoring smaller, acted datasets, this study investigates whether information learnt from acted emotions is useful for detecting natural emotions. Cross-corpus research has mostly considered cross-lingual and even cross-age datasets, and difficulties arise from different methods of annotating emotions causing a drop in performance. To be consistent, four adult English datasets covering acted, elicited and natural emotions are considered. A state-of-the-art model is proposed to accurately investigate the degradation of performance. The system involves a bi-directional LSTM with an attention mechanism to classify emotions across datasets. Experiments study the effects of training models in a cross-corpus and multi-domain fashion and results show the transfer of information is not successful. Out-of-domain models, followed by adapting to the missing dataset, and domain adversarial training (DAT) are shown to be more suitable to generalising to emotions across datasets. This shows positive information transfer from acted datasets to those with more natural emotions and the benefits from training on different corpora.

George Close, William Ravenscroft, Thomas Hain et al.

Recent work in the domain of speech enhancement has explored the use of self-supervised speech representations to aid in the training of neural speech enhancement models. However, much of this work focuses on using the deepest or final outputs of self supervised speech representation models, rather than the earlier feature encodings. The use of self supervised representations in such a way is often not fully motivated. In this work it is shown that the distance between the feature encodings of clean and noisy speech correlate strongly with psychoacoustically motivated measures of speech quality and intelligibility, as well as with human Mean Opinion Score (MOS) ratings. Experiments using this distance as a loss function are performed and improved performance over the use of STFT spectrogram distance based loss as well as other common loss functions from speech enhancement literature is demonstrated using objective measures such as perceptual evaluation of speech quality (PESQ) and short-time objective intelligibility (STOI).

William Ravenscroft, Stefan Goetze, Thomas Hain

Speech separation models are used for isolating individual speakers in many speech processing applications. Deep learning models have been shown to lead to state-of-the-art (SOTA) results on a number of speech separation benchmarks. One such class of models known as temporal convolutional networks (TCNs) has shown promising results for speech separation tasks. A limitation of these models is that they have a fixed receptive field (RF). Recent research in speech dereverberation has shown that the optimal RF of a TCN varies with the reverberation characteristics of the speech signal. In this work deformable convolution is proposed as a solution to allow TCN models to have dynamic RFs that can adapt to various reverberation times for reverberant speech separation. The proposed models are capable of achieving an 11.1 dB average scale-invariant signalto-distortion ratio (SISDR) improvement over the input signal on the WHAMR benchmark. A relatively small deformable TCN model of 1.3M parameters is proposed which gives comparable separation performance to larger and more computationally complex models.

George Close, Thomas Hain, Stefan Goetze

Training of speech enhancement systems often does not incorporate knowledge of human perception and thus can lead to unnatural sounding results. Incorporating psychoacoustically motivated speech perception metrics as part of model training via a predictor network has recently gained interest. However, the performance of such predictors is limited by the distribution of metric scores that appear in the training data. In this work, we propose MetricGAN+/- (an extension of MetricGAN+, one such metric-motivated system) which introduces an additional network - a "de-generator" which attempts to improve the robustness of the prediction network (and by extension of the generator) by ensuring observation of a wider range of metric scores in training. Experimental results on the VoiceBank-DEMAND dataset show relative improvement in PESQ score of 3.8% (3.05 vs 3.22 PESQ score), as well as better generalisation to unseen noise and speech.

George Close, Thomas Hain, Stefan Goetze

Recent work in the field of speech enhancement (SE) has involved the use of self-supervised speech representations (SSSRs) as feature transformations in loss functions. However, in prior work, very little attention has been paid to the relationship between the language of the audio used to train the self-supervised representation and that used to train the SE system. Enhancement models trained using a loss function which incorporates a self-supervised representation that shares exactly the language of the noisy data used to train the SE system show better performance than those which do not match exactly. This may lead to enhancement systems which are language specific and as such do not generalise well to unseen languages, unlike models trained using traditional spectrogram or time domain loss functions. In this work, SE models are trained and tested on a number of different languages, with self-supervised representations which themselves are trained using different language combinations and with differing network structures as loss function representations. These models are then tested across unseen languages and their performances are analysed. It is found that the training language of the self-supervised representation appears to have a minor effect on enhancement performance, the amount of training data of a particular language, however, greatly affects performance.

Anna Ollerenshaw, Md Asif Jalal, Thomas Hain

End-to-end automatic speech recognition (ASR) models aim to learn a generalised speech representation. However, there are limited tools available to understand the internal functions and the effect of hierarchical dependencies within the model architecture. It is crucial to understand the correlations between the layer-wise representations, to derive insights on the relationship between neural representations and performance. Previous investigations of network similarities using correlation analysis techniques have not been explored for End-to-End ASR models. This paper analyses and explores the internal dynamics between layers during training with CNN, LSTM and Transformer based approaches using Canonical correlation analysis (CCA) and centered kernel alignment (CKA) for the experiments. It was found that neural representations within CNN layers exhibit hierarchical correlation dependencies as layer depth increases but this is mostly limited to cases where neural representation correlates more closely. This behaviour is not observed in LSTM architecture, however there is a bottom-up pattern observed across the training process, while Transformer encoder layers exhibit irregular coefficiency correlation as neural depth increases. Altogether, these results provide new insights into the role that neural architectures have upon speech recognition performance. More specifically, these techniques can be used as indicators to build better performing speech recognition models.

William Ravenscroft, Stefan Goetze, Thomas Hain

Speech dereverberation is an important stage in many speech technology applications. Recent work in this area has been dominated by deep neural network models. Temporal convolutional networks (TCNs) are deep learning models that have been proposed for sequence modelling in the task of dereverberating speech. In this work a weighted multi-dilation depthwise-separable convolution is proposed to replace standard depthwise-separable convolutions in TCN models. This proposed convolution enables the TCN to dynamically focus on more or less local information in its receptive field at each convolutional block in the network. It is shown that this weighted multi-dilation temporal convolutional network (WD-TCN) consistently outperforms the TCN across various model configurations and using the WD-TCN model is a more parameter efficient method to improve the performance of the model than increasing the number of convolutional blocks. The best performance improvement over the baseline TCN is 0.55 dB scale-invariant signal-to-distortion ratio (SISDR) and the best performing WD-TCN model attains 12.26 dB SISDR on the WHAMR dataset.

William Ravenscroft, Stefan Goetze, Thomas Hain

Speech dereverberation is often an important requirement in robust speech processing tasks. Supervised deep learning (DL) models give state-of-the-art performance for single-channel speech dereverberation. Temporal convolutional networks (TCNs) are commonly used for sequence modelling in speech enhancement tasks. A feature of TCNs is that they have a receptive field (RF) dependent on the specific model configuration which determines the number of input frames that can be observed to produce an individual output frame. It has been shown that TCNs are capable of performing dereverberation of simulated speech data, however a thorough analysis, especially with focus on the RF is yet lacking in the literature. This paper analyses dereverberation performance depending on the model size and the RF of TCNs. Experiments using the WHAMR corpus which is extended to include room impulse responses (RIRs) with larger T60 values demonstrate that a larger RF can have significant improvement in performance when training smaller TCN models. It is also demonstrated that TCNs benefit from a wider RF when dereverberating RIRs with larger RT60 values.

George Close, Thomas Hain, Stefan Goetze

Self-supervised speech representations (SSSRs) have been successfully applied to a number of speech-processing tasks, e.g. as feature extractor for speech quality (SQ) prediction, which is, in turn, relevant for assessment and training speech enhancement systems for users with normal or impaired hearing. However, exact knowledge of why and how quality-related information is encoded well in such representations remains poorly understood. In this work, techniques for non-intrusive prediction of SQ ratings are extended to the prediction of intelligibility for hearing-impaired users. It is found that self-supervised representations are useful as input features to non-intrusive prediction models, achieving competitive performance to more complex systems. A detailed analysis of the performance depending on Clarity Prediction Challenge 1 listeners and enhancement systems indicates that more data might be needed to allow generalisation to unknown systems and (hearing-impaired) individuals

William Ravenscroft, Stefan Goetze, Thomas Hain

Speech separation remains an important area of multi-speaker signal processing. Deep neural network (DNN) models have attained the best performance on many speech separation benchmarks. Some of these models can take significant time to train and have high memory requirements. Previous work has proposed shortening training examples to address these issues but the impact of this on model performance is not yet well understood. In this work, the impact of applying these training signal length (TSL) limits is analysed for two speech separation models: SepFormer, a transformer model, and Conv-TasNet, a convolutional model. The WJS0-2Mix, WHAMR and Libri2Mix datasets are analysed in terms of signal length distribution and its impact on training efficiency. It is demonstrated that, for specific distributions, applying specific TSL limits results in better performance. This is shown to be mainly due to randomly sampling the start index of the waveforms resulting in more unique examples for training. A SepFormer model trained using a TSL limit of 4.42s and dynamic mixing (DM) is shown to match the best-performing SepFormer model trained with DM and unlimited signal lengths. Furthermore, the 4.42s TSL limit results in a 44% reduction in training time with WHAMR.

Muhammad Umar Farooq, Thomas Hain

Exploiting cross-lingual resources is an effective way to compensate for data scarcity of low resource languages. Recently, a novel multilingual model fusion technique has been proposed where a model is trained to learn cross-lingual acoustic-phonetic similarities as a mapping function. However, handcrafted lexicons have been used to train hybrid DNN-HMM ASR systems. To remove this dependency, we extend the concept of learnable cross-lingual mappings for end-to-end speech recognition. Furthermore, mapping models are employed to transliterate the source languages to the target language without using parallel data. Finally, the source audio and its transliteration is used for data augmentation to retrain the target language ASR. The results show that any source language ASR model can be used for a low-resource target language recognition followed by proposed mapping model. Furthermore, data augmentation results in a relative gain up to 5% over baseline monolingual model.

Muhammad Umar Farooq, Thomas Hain

Multilingual automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems mostly benefit low resource languages but suffer degradation in performance across several languages relative to their monolingual counterparts. Limited studies have focused on understanding the languages behaviour in the multilingual speech recognition setups. In this paper, a novel data-driven approach is proposed to investigate the cross-lingual acoustic-phonetic similarities. This technique measures the similarities between posterior distributions from various monolingual acoustic models against a target speech signal. Deep neural networks are trained as mapping networks to transform the distributions from different acoustic models into a directly comparable form. The analysis observes that the languages closeness can not be truly estimated by the volume of overlapping phonemes set. Entropy analysis of the proposed mapping networks exhibits that a language with lesser overlap can be more amenable to cross-lingual transfer, and hence more beneficial in the multilingual setup. Finally, the proposed posterior transformation approach is leveraged to fuse monolingual models for a target language. A relative improvement of ~8% over monolingual counterpart is achieved.

Muhammad Umar Farooq, Darshan Adiga Haniya Narayana, Thomas Hain

Multilingual speech recognition has drawn significant attention as an effective way to compensate data scarcity for low-resource languages. End-to-end (e2e) modelling is preferred over conventional hybrid systems, mainly because of no lexicon requirement. However, hybrid DNN-HMMs still outperform e2e models in limited data scenarios. Furthermore, the problem of manual lexicon creation has been alleviated by publicly available trained models of grapheme-to-phoneme (G2P) and text to IPA transliteration for a lot of languages. In this paper, a novel approach of hybrid DNN-HMM acoustic models fusion is proposed in a multilingual setup for the low-resource languages. Posterior distributions from different monolingual acoustic models, against a target language speech signal, are fused together. A separate regression neural network is trained for each source-target language pair to transform posteriors from source acoustic model to the target language. These networks require very limited data as compared to the ASR training. Posterior fusion yields a relative gain of 14.65% and 6.5% when compared with multilingual and monolingual baselines respectively. Cross-lingual model fusion shows that the comparable results can be achieved without using posteriors from the language dependent ASR.

Anna Ollerenshaw, Md Asif Jalal, Thomas Hain

End-to-End automatic speech recognition (ASR) models aim to learn a generalised speech representation to perform recognition. In this domain there is little research to analyse internal representation dependencies and their relationship to modelling approaches. This paper investigates cross-domain language model dependencies within transformer architectures using SVCCA and uses these insights to exploit modelling approaches. It was found that specific neural representations within the transformer layers exhibit correlated behaviour which impacts recognition performance. Altogether, this work provides analysis of the modelling approaches affecting contextual dependencies and ASR performance, and can be used to create or adapt better performing End-to-End ASR models and also for downstream tasks.

Cong-Thanh Do, Shuhei Imai, Rama Doddipatla et al.

This paper investigates the use of unsupervised text-to-speech synthesis (TTS) as a data augmentation method to improve accented speech recognition. TTS systems are trained with a small amount of accented speech training data and their pseudo-labels rather than manual transcriptions, and hence unsupervised. This approach enables the use of accented speech data without manual transcriptions to perform data augmentation for accented speech recognition. Synthetic accented speech data, generated from text prompts by using the TTS systems, are then combined with available non-accented speech data to train automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems. ASR experiments are performed in a self-supervised learning framework using a Wav2vec2.0 model which was pre-trained on large amount of unsupervised accented speech data. The accented speech data for training the unsupervised TTS are read speech, selected from L2-ARCTIC and British Isles corpora, while spontaneous conversational speech from the Edinburgh international accents of English corpus are used as the evaluation data. Experimental results show that Wav2vec2.0 models which are fine-tuned to downstream ASR task with synthetic accented speech data, generated by the unsupervised TTS, yield up to 6.1% relative word error rate reductions compared to a Wav2vec2.0 baseline which is fine-tuned with the non-accented speech data from Librispeech corpus.

Anna Ollerenshaw, Md Asif Jalal, Rosanna Milner et al.

Speech emotion recognition (SER) is vital for obtaining emotional intelligence and understanding the contextual meaning of speech. Variations of consonant-vowel (CV) phonemic boundaries can enrich acoustic context with linguistic cues, which impacts SER. In practice, speech emotions are treated as single labels over an acoustic segment for a given time duration. However, phone boundaries within speech are not discrete events, therefore the perceived emotion state should also be distributed over potentially continuous time-windows. This research explores the implication of acoustic context and phone boundaries on local markers for SER using an attention-based approach. The benefits of using a distributed approach to speech emotion understanding are supported by the results of cross-corpora analysis experiments. Experiments where phones and words are mapped to the attention vectors along with the fundamental frequency to observe the overlapping distributions and thereby the relationship between acoustic context and emotion. This work aims to bridge psycholinguistic theory research with computational modelling for SER.

Anna Ollerenshaw, Md Asif Jalal, Thomas Hain

State-of-the-art speaker verification frameworks have typically focused on developing models with increasingly deeper (more layers) and wider (number of channels) models to improve their verification performance. Instead, this paper proposes an approach to increase the model resolution capability using attention-based dynamic kernels in a convolutional neural network to adapt the model parameters to be feature-conditioned. The attention weights on the kernels are further distilled by channel attention and multi-layer feature aggregation to learn global features from speech. This approach provides an efficient solution to improving representation capacity with lower data resources. This is due to the self-adaptation to inputs of the structures of the model parameters. The proposed dynamic convolutional model achieved 1.62\% EER and 0.18 miniDCF on the VoxCeleb1 test set and has a 17\% relative improvement compared to the ECAPA-TDNN using the same training resources.

William Ravenscroft, Stefan Goetze, Thomas Hain

Speech separation remains an important topic for multi-speaker technology researchers. Convolution augmented transformers (conformers) have performed well for many speech processing tasks but have been under-researched for speech separation. Most recent state-of-the-art (SOTA) separation models have been time-domain audio separation networks (TasNets). A number of successful models have made use of dual-path (DP) networks which sequentially process local and global information. Time domain conformers (TD-Conformers) are an analogue of the DP approach in that they also process local and global context sequentially but have a different time complexity function. It is shown that for realistic shorter signal lengths, conformers are more efficient when controlling for feature dimension. Subsampling layers are proposed to further improve computational efficiency. The best TD-Conformer achieves 14.6 dB and 21.2 dB SISDR improvement on the WHAMR and WSJ0-2Mix benchmarks, respectively.

Chanho Park, Chengsong Lu, Mingjie Chen et al.

Word error rate (WER) estimation aims to evaluate the quality of an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system's output without requiring ground-truth labels. This task has gained increasing attention as advanced ASR systems are trained on large amounts of data. In this context, the computational efficiency of a WER estimator becomes essential in practice. However, previous works have not prioritised this aspect. In this paper, a Fast estimator for WER (Fe-WER) is introduced, utilizing average pooling over self-supervised learning representations for speech and text. Our results demonstrate that Fe-WER outperformed a baseline relatively by 14.10% in root mean square error and 1.22% in Pearson correlation coefficient on Ted-Lium3. Moreover, a comparative analysis of the distributions of target WER and WER estimates was conducted, including an examination of the average values per speaker. Lastly, the inference speed was approximately 3.4 times faster in the real-time factor.

Muhammad Umar Farooq, Rehan Ahmad, Thomas Hain

Student-teacher learning or knowledge distillation (KD) has been previously used to address data scarcity issue for training of speech recognition (ASR) systems. However, a limitation of KD training is that the student model classes must be a proper or improper subset of the teacher model classes. It prevents distillation from even acoustically similar languages if the character sets are not same. In this work, the aforementioned limitation is addressed by proposing a MUltilingual Student-Teacher (MUST) learning which exploits a posteriors mapping approach. A pre-trained mapping model is used to map posteriors from a teacher language to the student language ASR. These mapped posteriors are used as soft labels for KD learning. Various teacher ensemble schemes are experimented to train an ASR model for low-resource languages. A model trained with MUST learning reduces relative character error rate (CER) up to 9.5% in comparison with a baseline monolingual ASR.

Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain

There is a growing interest in cost-effective self-supervised fine-tuning (SSFT) of self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models to obtain task-specific representations. These task-specific representations are used for robust performance on various downstream tasks by fine-tuning on the labelled data. This work presents a cost-effective SSFT method named Self-supervised Correspondence (SCORE) fine-tuning to adapt the SSL speech representations for content-related tasks. The proposed method uses a correspondence training strategy, aiming to learn similar representations from perturbed speech and original speech. Commonly used data augmentation techniques for content-related tasks (ASR) are applied to obtain perturbed speech. SCORE fine-tuned HuBERT outperforms the vanilla HuBERT on SUPERB benchmark with only a few hours of fine-tuning (< 5 hrs) on a single GPU for automatic speech recognition, phoneme recognition, and query-by-example tasks, with relative improvements of 1.09%, 3.58%, and 12.65%, respectively. SCORE provides competitive results with the recently proposed SSFT method SPIN, using only 1/3 of the processed speech compared to SPIN.

George Close, Kris Hong, Thomas Hain et al.

There has been significant research effort developing neural-network-based predictors of SQ in recent years. While a primary objective has been to develop non-intrusive, i.e.~reference-free, metrics to assess the performance of SE systems, recent work has also investigated the direct inference of neural SQ predictors within the loss function of downstream speech tasks. To aid in the training of SQ predictors, several large datasets of audio with corresponding human labels of quality have been created. Recent work in this area has shown that speech representations derived from large unsupervised or semi-supervised foundational speech models are useful input feature representations for neural SQ prediction. In this work, a novel and robust SQ predictor is proposed based on feature representations extracted from an ASR model, found to be a powerful input feature for the SQ prediction task. The proposed system achieves higher correlation with human MOS ratings than recent approaches on all NISQA test sets and shows significantly better domain adaption compared to the commonly used DNSMOS metric.

Chanho Park, Mingjie Chen, Thomas Hain

Word error rate (WER) is a metric used to evaluate the quality of transcriptions produced by Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems. In many applications, it is of interest to estimate WER given a pair of a speech utterance and a transcript. Previous work on WER estimation focused on building models that are trained with a specific ASR system in mind (referred to as ASR system-dependent). These are also domain-dependent and inflexible in real-world applications. In this paper, a hypothesis generation method for ASR System-Independent WER estimation (SIWE) is proposed. In contrast to prior work, the WER estimators are trained using data that simulates ASR system output. Hypotheses are generated using phonetically similar or linguistically more likely alternative words. In WER estimation experiments, the proposed method reaches a similar performance to ASR system-dependent WER estimators on in-domain data and achieves state-of-the-art performance on out-of-domain data. On the out-of-domain data, the SIWE model outperformed the baseline estimators in root mean square error and Pearson correlation coefficient by relative 17.58% and 18.21%, respectively, on Switchboard and CALLHOME. The performance was further improved when the WER of the training set was close to the WER of the evaluation dataset.

Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain

Acoustic word embeddings (AWEs) are vector representations of spoken words. An effective method for obtaining AWEs is the Correspondence Auto-Encoder (CAE). In the past, the CAE method has been associated with traditional MFCC features. Representations obtained from self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models such as HuBERT, Wav2vec2, etc., are outperforming MFCC in many downstream tasks. However, they have not been well studied in the context of learning AWEs. This work explores the effectiveness of CAE with SSL-based speech representations to obtain improved AWEs. Additionally, the capabilities of SSL-based speech models are explored in cross-lingual scenarios for obtaining AWEs. Experiments are conducted on five languages: Polish, Portuguese, Spanish, French, and English. HuBERT-based CAE model achieves the best results for word discrimination in all languages, despite Hu-BERT being pre-trained on English only. Also, the HuBERT-based CAE model works well in cross-lingual settings. It outperforms MFCC-based CAE models trained on the target languages when trained on one source language and tested on target languages.

Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain

Integrating front-end speech enhancement (SE) models with self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models is effective for downstream tasks in noisy conditions. SE models are commonly fine-tuned using SSL representations with mean squared error (MSE) loss between enhanced and clean speech. However, MSE is prone to exploiting positional embeddings in SSL models, allowing the objective to be minimised through positional correlations instead of content-related information. This work frames the problem as a general limitation of self-supervised representation fine-tuning and investigates it through representation-guided SE. Two strategies are considered: (1) zero-padding, previously explored in SSL pre-training but here examined in the fine-tuning setting, and (2) speed perturbations with a soft-DTW loss. Experiments show that the soft-DTW-based approach achieves faster convergence and improved downstream performance, underscoring the importance of position-invariant fine-tuning in SSL-based speech modelling.

Shaun Cassini, Thomas Hain, Anton Ragni

This work investigates whether modern speech models are sensitive to prosodic emphasis - whether they encode emphasized and neutral words in systematically different ways. Prior work typically relies on isolated acoustic correlates (e.g., pitch, duration) or label prediction, both of which miss the relational structure of emphasis. This paper proposes a residual-based framework, defining emphasis as the difference between paired neutral and emphasized word representations. Analysis on self-supervised speech models shows that these residuals correlate strongly with duration changes and perform poorly at word identity prediction, indicating a structured, relational encoding of prosodic emphasis. In ASR fine-tuned models, residuals occupy a subspace up to 50% more compact than in pre-trained models, further suggesting that emphasis is encoded as a consistent, low-dimensional transformation that becomes more structured with task-specific learning.

Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain

Self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models are extensively used for full-stack speech processing. However, it has been observed that improving SSL-based speech representations using unlabeled speech for content-related tasks is challenging and computationally expensive. Recent attempts have been made to address this issue with cost-effective self-supervised fine-tuning (SSFT) approaches. Continuing in this direction, a cost-effective SSFT method named "LASER: Learning by Aligning Self-supervised Representations" is presented. LASER is based on the soft-DTW alignment loss with temporal regularisation term. Experiments are conducted with HuBERT and WavLM models and evaluated on the SUPERB benchmark for two content-related tasks: automatic speech recognition (ASR) and phoneme recognition (PR). A relative improvement of 3.7% and 8.2% for HuBERT, and 4.1% and 11.7% for WavLM are observed, for the ASR and PR tasks respectively, with only < 3 hours of fine-tuning on a single GPU.

William Ravenscroft, George Close, Stefan Goetze et al.

One solution to automatic speech recognition (ASR) of overlapping speakers is to separate speech and then perform ASR on the separated signals. Commonly, the separator produces artefacts which often degrade ASR performance. Addressing this issue typically requires reference transcriptions to jointly train the separation and ASR networks. This is often not viable for training on real-world in-domain audio where reference transcript information is not always available. This paper proposes a transcription-free method for joint training using only audio signals. The proposed method uses embedding differences of pre-trained ASR encoders as a loss with a proposed modification to permutation invariant training (PIT) called guided PIT (GPIT). The method achieves a 6.4% improvement in word error rate (WER) measures over a signal-level loss and also shows enhancement improvements in perceptual measures such as short-time objective intelligibility (STOI).

Ziyang Ma, Mingjie Chen, Hezhao Zhang et al.

Speech emotion recognition (SER) is an important part of human-computer interaction, receiving extensive attention from both industry and academia. However, the current research field of SER has long suffered from the following problems: 1) There are few reasonable and universal splits of the datasets, making comparing different models and methods difficult. 2) No commonly used benchmark covers numerous corpus and languages for researchers to refer to, making reproduction a burden. In this paper, we propose EmoBox, an out-of-the-box multilingual multi-corpus speech emotion recognition toolkit, along with a benchmark for both intra-corpus and cross-corpus settings. For intra-corpus settings, we carefully designed the data partitioning for different datasets. For cross-corpus settings, we employ a foundation SER model, emotion2vec, to mitigate annotation errors and obtain a test set that is fully balanced in speakers and emotions distributions. Based on EmoBox, we present the intra-corpus SER results of 10 pre-trained speech models on 32 emotion datasets with 14 languages, and the cross-corpus SER results on 4 datasets with the fully balanced test sets. To the best of our knowledge, this is the largest SER benchmark, across language scopes and quantity scales. We hope that our toolkit and benchmark can facilitate the research of SER in the community.

Rhiannon Mogridge, George Close, Robert Sutherland et al.

Neural networks have been successfully used for non-intrusive speech intelligibility prediction. Recently, the use of feature representations sourced from intermediate layers of pre-trained self-supervised and weakly-supervised models has been found to be particularly useful for this task. This work combines the use of Whisper ASR decoder layer representations as neural network input features with an exemplar-based, psychologically motivated model of human memory to predict human intelligibility ratings for hearing-aid users. Substantial performance improvement over an established intrusive HASPI baseline system is found, including on enhancement systems and listeners unseen in the training data, with a root mean squared error of 25.3 compared with the baseline of 28.7.

Cong-Thanh Do, Rama Doddipatla, Thomas Hain

This paper proposes an adaptation method for end-to-end speech recognition. In this method, multiple automatic speech recognition (ASR) 1-best hypotheses are integrated in the computation of the connectionist temporal classification (CTC) loss function. The integration of multiple ASR hypotheses helps alleviating the impact of errors in the ASR hypotheses to the computation of the CTC loss when ASR hypotheses are used. When being applied in semi-supervised adaptation scenarios where part of the adaptation data do not have labels, the CTC loss of the proposed method is computed from different ASR 1-best hypotheses obtained by decoding the unlabeled adaptation data. Experiments are performed in clean and multi-condition training scenarios where the CTC-based end-to-end ASR systems are trained on Wall Street Journal (WSJ) clean training data and CHiME-4 multi-condition training data, respectively, and tested on Aurora-4 test data. The proposed adaptation method yields 6.6% and 5.8% relative word error rate (WER) reductions in clean and multi-condition training scenarios, respectively, compared to a baseline system which is adapted with part of the adaptation data having manual transcriptions using back-propagation fine-tuning.

Yanpei Shi, Mingjie Chen, Qiang Huang et al.

Identifying multiple speakers without knowing where a speaker's voice is in a recording is a challenging task. This paper proposes a hierarchical network with transformer encoders and memory mechanism to address this problem. The proposed model contains a frame-level encoder and segment-level encoder, both of them make use of the transformer encoder block. The multi-head attention mechanism in the transformer structure could better capture different speaker properties when the input utterance contains multiple speakers. The memory mechanism used in the frame-level encoders can build a recurrent connection that better capture long-term speaker features. The experiments are conducted on artificial datasets based on the Switchboard Cellular part1 (SWBC) and Voxceleb1 datasets. In different data construction scenarios (Concat and Overlap), the proposed model shows better performance comparaing with four strong baselines, reaching 13.3% and 10.5% relative improvement compared with H-vectors and S-vectors. The use of memory mechanism could reach 10.6% and 7.7% relative improvement compared with not using memory mechanism.

Mingjie Chen, Yanpei Shi, Thomas Hain

Many-to-many voice conversion with non-parallel training data has seen significant progress in recent years. StarGAN-based models have been interests of voice conversion. However, most of the StarGAN-based methods only focused on voice conversion experiments for the situations where the number of speakers was small, and the amount of training data was large. In this work, we aim at improving the data efficiency of the model and achieving a many-to-many non-parallel StarGAN-based voice conversion for a relatively large number of speakers with limited training samples. In order to improve data efficiency, the proposed model uses a speaker encoder for extracting speaker embeddings and conducts adaptive instance normalization (AdaIN) on convolutional weights. Experiments are conducted with 109 speakers under two low-resource situations, where the number of training samples is 20 and 5 per speaker. An objective evaluation shows the proposed model is better than the baseline methods. Furthermore, a subjective evaluation shows that, for both naturalness and similarity, the proposed model outperforms the baseline method.

Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

Anomalous audio in speech recordings is often caused by speaker voice distortion, external noise, or even electric interferences. These obstacles have become a serious problem in some fields, such as high-quality music mixing and speech processing. In this paper, a novel approach using a temporal convolutional attention network (TCAN) is proposed to tackle this problem. The use of temporal conventional network (TCN) can capture long range patterns using a hierarchy of temporal convolutional filters. To enhance the ability to tackle audio anomalies in different acoustic conditions, an attention mechanism is used in TCN, where a self-attention block is added after each temporal convolutional layer. This aims to highlight the target related features and mitigate the interferences from irrelevant information. To evaluate the performance of the proposed model, audio recordings are collected from the TIMIT dataset, and are then changed by adding five different types of audio distortions: gaussian noise, magnitude drift, random dropout, reduction of temporal resolution, and time warping. Distortions are mixed at different signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) (5dB, 10dB, 15dB, 20dB, 25dB, 30dB). The experimental results show that the use of proposed model can yield better classification performances than some strong baseline methods, such as the LSTM and TCN based models, by approximate 3$\sim$ 10\% relative improvements.

Mingjie Chen, Thomas Hain

Unsupervised representation learning of speech has been of keen interest in recent years, which is for example evident in the wide interest of the ZeroSpeech challenges. This work presents a new method for learning frame level representations based on WaveNet auto-encoders. Of particular interest in the ZeroSpeech Challenge 2019 were models with discrete latent variable such as the Vector Quantized Variational Auto-Encoder (VQVAE). However these models generate speech with relatively poor quality. In this work we aim to address this with two approaches: first WaveNet is used as the decoder and to generate waveform data directly from the latent representation; second, the low complexity of latent representations is improved with two alternative disentanglement learning methods, namely instance normalization and sliced vector quantization. The method was developed and tested in the context of the recent ZeroSpeech challenge 2020. The system output submitted to the challenge obtained the top position for naturalness (Mean Opinion Score 4.06), top position for intelligibility (Character Error Rate 0.15), and third position for the quality of the representation (ABX test score 12.5). These and further analysis in this paper illustrates that quality of the converted speech and the acoustic units representation can be well balanced.

Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

Many applications of speech technology require more and more audio data. Automatic assessment of the quality of the collected recordings is important to ensure they meet the requirements of the related applications. However, effective and high performing assessment remains a challenging task without a clean reference. In this paper, a novel model for audio quality assessment is proposed by jointly using bidirectional long short-term memory and an attention mechanism. The former is to mimic a human auditory perception ability to learn information from a recording, and the latter is to further discriminate interferences from desired signals by highlighting target related features. To evaluate our proposed approach, the TIMIT dataset is used and augmented by mixing with various natural sounds. In our experiments, two tasks are explored. The first task is to predict an utterance quality score, and the second is to identify where an anomalous distortion takes place in a recording. The obtained results show that the use of our proposed approach outperforms a strong baseline method and gains about 5% improvements after being measured by three metrics, Linear Correlation Coefficient and Spearman Rank Correlation Coefficient, and F1.

Yanpei Shi, Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

While the use of deep neural networks has significantly boosted speaker recognition performance, it is still challenging to separate speakers in poor acoustic environments. Here speech enhancement methods have traditionally allowed improved performance. The recent works have shown that adapting speech enhancement can lead to further gains. This paper introduces a novel approach that cascades speech enhancement and speaker recognition. In the first step, a speaker embedding vector is generated , which is used in the second step to enhance the speech quality and re-identify the speakers. Models are trained in an integrated framework with joint optimisation. The proposed approach is evaluated using the Voxceleb1 dataset, which aims to assess speaker recognition in real world situations. In addition three types of noise at different signal-noise-ratios were added for this work. The obtained results show that the proposed approach using speaker dependent speech enhancement can yield better speaker recognition and speech enhancement performances than two baselines in various noise conditions.

Yanpei Shi, Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

Identifying multiple speakers without knowing where a speaker's voice is in a recording is a challenging task. In this paper, a hierarchical attention network is proposed to solve a weakly labelled speaker identification problem. The use of a hierarchical structure, consisting of a frame-level encoder and a segment-level encoder, aims to learn speaker related information locally and globally. Speech streams are segmented into fragments. The frame-level encoder with attention learns features and highlights the target related frames locally, and output a fragment based embedding. The segment-level encoder works with a second attention layer to emphasize the fragments probably related to target speakers. The global information is finally collected from segment-level module to predict speakers via a classifier. To evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed approach, artificial datasets based on Switchboard Cellular part1 (SWBC) and Voxceleb1 are constructed in two conditions, where speakers' voices are overlapped and not overlapped. Comparing to two baselines the obtained results show that the proposed approach can achieve better performances. Moreover, further experiments are conducted to evaluate the impact of utterance segmentation. The results show that a reasonable segmentation can slightly improve identification performances.

Yanpei Shi, Thomas Hain

Separating different speaker properties from a multi-speaker environment is challenging. Instead of separating a two-speaker signal in signal space like speech source separation, a speaker embedding de-mixing approach is proposed. The proposed approach separates different speaker properties from a two-speaker signal in embedding space. The proposed approach contains two steps. In step one, the clean speaker embeddings are learned and collected by a residual TDNN based network. In step two, the two-speaker signal and the embedding of one of the speakers are both input to a speaker embedding de-mixing network. The de-mixing network is trained to generate the embedding of the other speaker by reconstruction loss. Speaker identification accuracy and the cosine similarity score between the clean embeddings and the de-mixed embeddings are used to evaluate the quality of the obtained embeddings. Experiments are done in two kind of data: artificial augmented two-speaker data (TIMIT) and real world recording of two-speaker data (MC-WSJ). Six different speaker embedding de-mixing architectures are investigated. Comparing with the performance on the clean speaker embeddings, the obtained results show that one of the proposed architectures obtained close performance, reaching 96.9% identification accuracy and 0.89 cosine similarity.

Yanpei Shi, Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

In this paper, a novel architecture for speaker recognition is proposed by cascading speech enhancement and speaker processing. Its aim is to improve speaker recognition performance when speech signals are corrupted by noise. Instead of individually processing speech enhancement and speaker recognition, the two modules are integrated into one framework by a joint optimisation using deep neural networks. Furthermore, to increase robustness against noise, a multi-stage attention mechanism is employed to highlight the speaker related features learned from context information in time and frequency domain. To evaluate speaker identification and verification performance of the proposed approach, we test it on the dataset of VoxCeleb1, one of mostly used benchmark datasets. Moreover, the robustness of our proposed approach is also tested on VoxCeleb1 data when being corrupted by three types of interferences, general noise, music, and babble, at different signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) levels. The obtained results show that the proposed approach using speech enhancement and multi-stage attention models outperforms two strong baselines not using them in most acoustic conditions in our experiments.

Yanpei Shi, Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

In this paper, a hierarchical attention network to generate utterance-level embeddings (H-vectors) for speaker identification is proposed. Since different parts of an utterance may have different contributions to speaker identities, the use of hierarchical structure aims to learn speaker related information locally and globally. In the proposed approach, frame-level encoder and attention are applied on segments of an input utterance and generate individual segment vectors. Then, segment level attention is applied on the segment vectors to construct an utterance representation. To evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed approach, NIST SRE 2008 Part1 dataset is used for training, and two datasets, Switchboard Cellular part1 and CallHome American English Speech, are used to evaluate the quality of extracted utterance embeddings on speaker identification and verification tasks. In comparison with two baselines, X-vector, X-vector+Attention, the obtained results show that H-vectors can achieve a significantly better performance. Furthermore, the extracted utterance-level embeddings are more discriminative than the two baselines when mapped into a 2D space using t-SNE.

Yanpei Shi, Thomas Hain

Embedding acoustic information into fixed length representations is of interest for a whole range of applications in speech and audio technology. Two novel unsupervised approaches to generate acoustic embeddings by modelling of acoustic context are proposed. The first approach is a contextual joint factor synthesis encoder, where the encoder in an encoder/decoder framework is trained to extract joint factors from surrounding audio frames to best generate the target output. The second approach is a contextual joint factor analysis encoder, where the encoder is trained to analyse joint factors from the source signal that correlates best with the neighbouring audio. To evaluate the effectiveness of our approaches compared to prior work, two tasks are conducted -- phone classification and speaker recognition -- and test on different TIMIT data sets. Experimental results show that one of the proposed approaches outperforms phone classification baselines, yielding a classification accuracy of 74.1%. When using additional out-of-domain data for training, an additional 3% improvements can be obtained, for both for phone classification and speaker recognition tasks.

Yanpei Shi, Qiang Huang, Thomas Hain

While the use of deep neural networks has significantly boosted speaker recognition performance, it is still challenging to separate speakers in poor acoustic environments. To improve robustness of speaker recognition system performance in noise, a novel two-stage attention mechanism which can be used in existing architectures such as Time Delay Neural Networks (TDNNs) and Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) is proposed. Noise is known to often mask important information in both time and frequency domain. The proposed mechanism allows the models to concentrate on reliable time/frequency components of the signal. The proposed approach is evaluated using the Voxceleb1 dataset, which aims at assessment of speaker recognition in real world situations. In addition three types of noise at different signal-noise-ratios (SNRs) were added for this work. The proposed mechanism is compared with three strong baselines: X-vectors, Attentive X-vector, and Resnet-34. Results on both identification and verification tasks show that the two-stage attention mechanism consistently improves upon these for all noise conditions.

Mortaza, Doulaty, Thomas Hain

Selecting in-domain data from a large pool of diverse and out-of-domain data is a non-trivial problem. In most cases simply using all of the available data will lead to sub-optimal and in some cases even worse performance compared to carefully selecting a matching set. This is true even for data-inefficient neural models. Acoustic Latent Dirichlet Allocation (aLDA) is shown to be useful in a variety of speech technology related tasks, including domain adaptation of acoustic models for automatic speech recognition and entity labeling for information retrieval. In this paper we propose to use aLDA as a data similarity criterion in a data selection framework. Given a large pool of out-of-domain and potentially mismatched data, the task is to select the best-matching training data to a set of representative utterances sampled from a target domain. Our target data consists of around 32 hours of meeting data (both far-field and close-talk) and the pool contains 2k hours of meeting, talks, voice search, dictation, command-and-control, audio books, lectures, generic media and telephony speech data. The proposed technique for training data selection, significantly outperforms random selection, posterior-based selection as well as using all of the available data.

Mortaza Doulaty, Oscar Saz, Raymond W. M. Ng et al.

Huge amounts of digital videos are being produced and broadcast every day, leading to giant media archives. Effective techniques are needed to make such data accessible further. Automatic meta-data labelling of broadcast media is an essential task for multimedia indexing, where it is standard to use multi-modal input for such purposes. This paper describes a novel method for automatic detection of media genre and show identities using acoustic features, textual features or a combination thereof. Furthermore the inclusion of available meta-data, such as time of broadcast, is shown to lead to very high performance. Latent Dirichlet Allocation is used to model both acoustics and text, yielding fixed dimensional representations of media recordings that can then be used in Support Vector Machines based classification. Experiments are conducted on more than 1200 hours of TV broadcasts from the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC), where the task is to categorise the broadcasts into 8 genres or 133 show identities. On a 200-hour test set, accuracies of 98.6% and 85.7% were achieved for genre and show identification respectively, using a combination of acoustic and textual features with meta-data.

Oscar Saz, Mortaza Doulaty, Salil Deena et al.

We describe the University of Sheffield system for participation in the 2015 Multi-Genre Broadcast (MGB) challenge task of transcribing multi-genre broadcast shows. Transcription was one of four tasks proposed in the MGB challenge, with the aim of advancing the state of the art of automatic speech recognition, speaker diarisation and automatic alignment of subtitles for broadcast media. Four topics are investigated in this work: Data selection techniques for training with unreliable data, automatic speech segmentation of broadcast media shows, acoustic modelling and adaptation in highly variable environments, and language modelling of multi-genre shows. The final system operates in multiple passes, using an initial unadapted decoding stage to refine segmentation, followed by three adapted passes: a hybrid DNN pass with input features normalised by speaker-based cepstral normalisation, another hybrid stage with input features normalised by speaker feature-MLLR transformations, and finally a bottleneck-based tandem stage with noise and speaker factorisation. The combination of these three system outputs provides a final error rate of 27.5% on the official development set, consisting of 47 multi-genre shows.

Mortaza Doulaty, Oscar Saz, Raymond W. M. Ng et al.

This paper presents a new method for the discovery of latent domains in diverse speech data, for the use of adaptation of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for Automatic Speech Recognition. Our work focuses on transcription of multi-genre broadcast media, which is often only categorised broadly in terms of high level genres such as sports, news, documentary, etc. However, in terms of acoustic modelling these categories are coarse. Instead, it is expected that a mixture of latent domains can better represent the complex and diverse behaviours within a TV show, and therefore lead to better and more robust performance. We propose a new method, whereby these latent domains are discovered with Latent Dirichlet Allocation, in an unsupervised manner. These are used to adapt DNNs using the Unique Binary Code (UBIC) representation for the LDA domains. Experiments conducted on a set of BBC TV broadcasts, with more than 2,000 shows for training and 47 shows for testing, show that the use of LDA-UBIC DNNs reduces the error up to 13% relative compared to the baseline hybrid DNN models.

Oscar Saz, Mortaza Doulaty, Thomas Hain

This paper presents a novel method for extracting acoustic features that characterise the background environment in audio recordings. These features are based on the output of an alignment that fits multiple parallel background--based Constrained Maximum Likelihood Linear Regression transformations asynchronously to the input audio signal. With this setup, the resulting features can track changes in the audio background like appearance and disappearance of music, applause or laughter, independently of the speakers in the foreground of the audio. The ability to provide this type of acoustic description in audiovisual data has many potential applications, including automatic classification of broadcast archives or improving automatic transcription and subtitling. In this paper, the performance of these features in a genre identification task in a set of 332 BBC shows is explored. The proposed background--tracking features outperform short--term Perceptual Linear Prediction features in this task using Gaussian Mixture Model classifiers (62% vs 72% accuracy). The use of more complex classifiers, Hidden Markov Models and Support Vector Machines, increases the performance of the system with the novel background--tracking features to 79% and 81% in accuracy respectively.

Raymond W. M. Ng, Mortaza Doulaty, Rama Doddipatla et al.

The University of Sheffield (USFD) participated in the International Workshop for Spoken Language Translation (IWSLT) in 2014. In this paper, we will introduce the USFD SLT system for IWSLT. Automatic speech recognition (ASR) is achieved by two multi-pass deep neural network systems with adaptation and rescoring techniques. Machine translation (MT) is achieved by a phrase-based system. The USFD primary system incorporates state-of-the-art ASR and MT techniques and gives a BLEU score of 23.45 and 14.75 on the English-to-French and English-to-German speech-to-text translation task with the IWSLT 2014 data. The USFD contrastive systems explore the integration of ASR and MT by using a quality estimation system to rescore the ASR outputs, optimising towards better translation. This gives a further 0.54 and 0.26 BLEU improvement respectively on the IWSLT 2012 and 2014 evaluation data.

Mortaza Doulaty, Oscar Saz, Thomas Hain

Speech recognition systems are often highly domain dependent, a fact widely reported in the literature. However the concept of domain is complex and not bound to clear criteria. Hence it is often not evident if data should be considered to be out-of-domain. While both acoustic and language models can be domain specific, work in this paper concentrates on acoustic modelling. We present a novel method to perform unsupervised discovery of domains using Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) modelling. Here a set of hidden domains is assumed to exist in the data, whereby each audio segment can be considered to be a weighted mixture of domain properties. The classification of audio segments into domains allows the creation of domain specific acoustic models for automatic speech recognition. Experiments are conducted on a dataset of diverse speech data covering speech from radio and TV broadcasts, telephone conversations, meetings, lectures and read speech, with a joint training set of 60 hours and a test set of 6 hours. Maximum A Posteriori (MAP) adaptation to LDA based domains was shown to yield relative Word Error Rate (WER) improvements of up to 16% relative, compared to pooled training, and up to 10%, compared with models adapted with human-labelled prior domain knowledge.