CVNov 22, 2023Code
Feature Extraction for Generative Medical Imaging Evaluation: New Evidence Against an Evolving TrendMcKell Woodland, Austin Castelo, Mais Al Taie et al.
Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) is a widely used metric for assessing synthetic image quality. It relies on an ImageNet-based feature extractor, making its applicability to medical imaging unclear. A recent trend is to adapt FID to medical imaging through feature extractors trained on medical images. Our study challenges this practice by demonstrating that ImageNet-based extractors are more consistent and aligned with human judgment than their RadImageNet counterparts. We evaluated sixteen StyleGAN2 networks across four medical imaging modalities and four data augmentation techniques with Fréchet distances (FDs) computed using eleven ImageNet or RadImageNet-trained feature extractors. Comparison with human judgment via visual Turing tests revealed that ImageNet-based extractors produced rankings consistent with human judgment, with the FD derived from the ImageNet-trained SwAV extractor significantly correlating with expert evaluations. In contrast, RadImageNet-based rankings were volatile and inconsistent with human judgment. Our findings challenge prevailing assumptions, providing novel evidence that medical image-trained feature extractors do not inherently improve FDs and can even compromise their reliability. Our code is available at https://github.com/mckellwoodland/fid-med-eval.
IVOct 7, 2022
Evaluating the Performance of StyleGAN2-ADA on Medical ImagesMcKell Woodland, John Wood, Brian M. Anderson et al.
Although generative adversarial networks (GANs) have shown promise in medical imaging, they have four main limitations that impeded their utility: computational cost, data requirements, reliable evaluation measures, and training complexity. Our work investigates each of these obstacles in a novel application of StyleGAN2-ADA to high-resolution medical imaging datasets. Our dataset is comprised of liver-containing axial slices from non-contrast and contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT) scans. Additionally, we utilized four public datasets composed of various imaging modalities. We trained a StyleGAN2 network with transfer learning (from the Flickr-Faces-HQ dataset) and data augmentation (horizontal flipping and adaptive discriminator augmentation). The network's generative quality was measured quantitatively with the Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) and qualitatively with a visual Turing test given to seven radiologists and radiation oncologists. The StyleGAN2-ADA network achieved a FID of 5.22 ($\pm$ 0.17) on our liver CT dataset. It also set new record FIDs of 10.78, 3.52, 21.17, and 5.39 on the publicly available SLIVER07, ChestX-ray14, ACDC, and Medical Segmentation Decathlon (brain tumors) datasets. In the visual Turing test, the clinicians rated generated images as real 42% of the time, approaching random guessing. Our computational ablation study revealed that transfer learning and data augmentation stabilize training and improve the perceptual quality of the generated images. We observed the FID to be consistent with human perceptual evaluation of medical images. Finally, our work found that StyleGAN2-ADA consistently produces high-quality results without hyperparameter searches or retraining.
NCNov 11, 2022
Accounting for Temporal Variability in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Improves Prediction of IntelligenceYang Li, Xin Ma, Raj Sunderraman et al.
Neuroimaging-based prediction methods for intelligence and cognitive abilities have seen a rapid development in literature. Among different neuroimaging modalities, prediction based on functional connectivity (FC) has shown great promise. Most literature has focused on prediction using static FC, but there are limited investigations on the merits of such analysis compared to prediction based on dynamic FC or region level functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) times series that encode temporal variability. To account for the temporal dynamics in fMRI data, we propose a deep neural network involving bi-directional long short-term memory (bi-LSTM) approach that also incorporates feature selection mechanism. The proposed pipeline is implemented via an efficient GPU computation framework and applied to predict intelligence scores based on region level fMRI time series as well as dynamic FC. We compare the prediction performance for different intelligence measures based on static FC, dynamic FC, and region level time series acquired from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study involving close to 7000 individuals. Our detailed analysis illustrates that static FC consistently has inferior prediction performance compared to region level time series or dynamic FC for unimodal rest and task fMRI experiments, and in almost all cases using a combination of task and rest features. In addition, the proposed bi-LSTM pipeline based on region level time series identifies several shared and differential important brain regions across task and rest fMRI experiments that drive intelligence prediction. A test-retest analysis of the selected features shows strong reliability across cross-validation folds. Given the large sample size from ABCD study, our results provide strong evidence that superior prediction of intelligence can be achieved by accounting for temporal variations in fMRI.
NCSep 12, 2023
Bayesian longitudinal tensor response regression for modeling neuroplasticitySuprateek Kundu, Alec Reinhardt, Serena Song et al.
A major interest in longitudinal neuroimaging studies involves investigating voxel-level neuroplasticity due to treatment and other factors across visits. However, traditional voxel-wise methods are beset with several pitfalls, which can compromise the accuracy of these approaches. We propose a novel Bayesian tensor response regression approach for longitudinal imaging data, which pools information across spatially-distributed voxels to infer significant changes while adjusting for covariates. The proposed method, which is implemented using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling, utilizes low-rank decomposition to reduce dimensionality and preserve spatial configurations of voxels when estimating coefficients. It also enables feature selection via joint credible regions which respect the shape of the posterior distributions for more accurate inference. In addition to group level inferences, the method is able to infer individual-level neuroplasticity, allowing for examination of personalized disease or recovery trajectories. The advantages of the proposed approach in terms of prediction and feature selection over voxel-wise regression are highlighted via extensive simulation studies. Subsequently, we apply the approach to a longitudinal Aphasia dataset consisting of task functional MRI images from a group of subjects who were administered either a control intervention or intention treatment at baseline and were followed up over subsequent visits. Our analysis revealed that while the control therapy showed long-term increases in brain activity, the intention treatment produced predominantly short-term changes, both of which were concentrated in distinct localized regions. In contrast, the voxel-wise regression failed to detect any significant neuroplasticity after multiplicity adjustments, which is biologically implausible and implies lack of power.
CVJul 25, 2025
DeepJIVE: Learning Joint and Individual Variation Explained from Multimodal Data Using Deep LearningMatthew Drexler, Benjamin Risk, James J Lah et al.
Conventional multimodal data integration methods provide a comprehensive assessment of the shared or unique structure within each individual data type but suffer from several limitations such as the inability to handle high-dimensional data and identify nonlinear structures. In this paper, we introduce DeepJIVE, a deep-learning approach to performing Joint and Individual Variance Explained (JIVE). We perform mathematical derivation and experimental validations using both synthetic and real-world 1D, 2D, and 3D datasets. Different strategies of achieving the identity and orthogonality constraints for DeepJIVE were explored, resulting in three viable loss functions. We found that DeepJIVE can successfully uncover joint and individual variations of multimodal datasets. Our application of DeepJIVE to the Alzheimer's Disease Neuroimaging Initiative (ADNI) also identified biologically plausible covariation patterns between the amyloid positron emission tomography (PET) and magnetic resonance (MR) images. In conclusion, the proposed DeepJIVE can be a useful tool for multimodal data analysis.
APMar 11, 2024
Heterogeneous Image-based Classification Using Distributional Data AnalysisAlec Reinhardt, Newsha Nikzad, Raven J. Hollis et al.
Diagnostic imaging has gained prominence as potential biomarkers for early detection and diagnosis in a diverse array of disorders including cancer. However, existing methods routinely face challenges arising from various factors such as image heterogeneity. We develop a novel imaging-based distributional data analysis (DDA) approach that incorporates the probability (quantile) distribution of the pixel-level features as covariates. The proposed approach uses a smoothed quantile distribution (via a suitable basis representation) as functional predictors in a scalar-on-functional quantile regression model. Some distinctive features of the proposed approach include the ability to: (i) account for heterogeneity within the image; (ii) incorporate granular information spanning the entire distribution; and (iii) tackle variability in image sizes for unregistered images in cancer applications. Our primary goal is risk prediction in Hepatocellular carcinoma that is achieved via predicting the change in tumor grades at post-diagnostic visits using pre-diagnostic enhancement pattern mapping (EPM) images of the liver. Along the way, the proposed DDA approach is also used for case versus control diagnosis and risk stratification objectives. Our analysis reveals that when coupled with global structural radiomics features derived from the corresponding T1-MRI scans, the proposed smoothed quantile distributions derived from EPM images showed considerable improvements in sensitivity and comparable specificity in contrast to classification based on routinely used summary measures that do not account for image heterogeneity. Given that there are limited predictive modeling approaches based on heterogeneous images in cancer, the proposed method is expected to provide considerable advantages in image-based early detection and risk prediction.
CVMay 24, 2021
Elastic Shape Analysis of Brain Structures for Predictive Modeling of PTSDYuexuan Wu, Suprateek Kundu, Jennifer S. Stevens et al.
There is increasing evidence on the importance of brain morphology in predicting and classifying mental disorders. However, the vast majority of current shape approaches rely heavily on vertex-wise analysis that may not successfully capture complexities of subcortical structures. Additionally, the past works do not include interactions between these structures and exposure factors. Predictive modeling with such interactions is of paramount interest in heterogeneous mental disorders such as PTSD, where trauma exposure interacts with brain shape changes to influence behavior. We propose a comprehensive framework that overcomes these limitations by representing brain substructures as continuous parameterized surfaces and quantifying their shape differences using elastic shape metrics. Using the elastic shape metric, we compute shape summaries of subcortical data and represent individual shapes by their principal scores. These representations allow visualization tools that help localize changes when these PCs are varied. Subsequently, these PCs, the auxiliary exposure variables, and their interactions are used for regression modeling. We apply our method to data from the Grady Trauma Project, where the goal is to predict clinical measures of PTSD using shapes of brain substructures. Our analysis revealed considerably greater predictive power under the elastic shape analysis than widely used approaches such as vertex-wise shape analysis and even volumetric analysis. It helped identify local deformations in brain shapes related to change in PTSD severity. To our knowledge, this is one of the first brain shape analysis approaches that can seamlessly integrate the pre-processing steps under one umbrella for improved accuracy and are naturally able to account for interactions between brain shape and additional covariates to yield superior predictive performance when modeling clinical outcomes.