František Plášil

Michal Töpfer, František Plášil, Tomáš Bureš et al.

Online machine learning (ML) is often used in self-adaptive systems to strengthen the adaptation mechanism and improve the system utility. Despite such benefits, applying online ML for self-adaptation can be challenging, and not many papers report its limitations. Recently, we experimented with applying online ML for self-adaptation of a smart farming scenario and we had faced several unexpected difficulties -- traps -- that, to our knowledge, are not discussed enough in the community. In this paper, we report our experience with these traps. Specifically, we discuss several traps that relate to the specification and online training of the ML-based estimators, their impact on self-adaptation, and the approach used to evaluate the estimators. Our overview of these traps provides a list of lessons learned, which can serve as guidance for other researchers and practitioners when applying online ML for self-adaptation.

Michal Töpfer, František Plášil, Tomáš Bureš et al.

Vibe coding inherently assumes iterative refinement of LLM-generated code through feedback loops. While effective for conventional software tasks, its reliability in runtime-adaptive systems is unclear -- especially when generated code is not manually inspected. This paper studies feedback-based automated verification of LLM-generated adaptation managers in Collective Adaptive Systems (CAS). We focus on the key challenges of verification in the loop: how to detect failures of generated code at runtime and how to report them precisely enough for an LLM to fix them. We combine the adaptation loop with a vibe-coding feedback loop where correctness is checked against (i) generic architectural constraints and (ii) functional constraints formalized in Functional Constraints Logic (FCL), a novel first-order temporal logic over potentially finite traces. Conducting the Dragon Hunt CAS case study, we show that fine-grained constraint violations provide actionable feedback that typically yields a valid adaptation manager within a few iterations, while simple coarse metric-based feedback often stalls. Our findings suggest that feedback precision is the dominant factor for reliable vibe coding in systems designed by domain experts with no programming skills, thereby obviating the need for human code inspection.