V. Akshay

E. Campos, D. Rabinovich, V. Akshay et al.

Quantum Approximate Optimisation (QAOA) is the most studied gate based variational quantum algorithm today. We train QAOA one layer at a time to maximize overlap with an $n$ qubit target state. Doing so we discovered that such training always saturates -- called \textit{training saturation} -- at some depth $p^*$, meaning that past a certain depth, overlap can not be improved by adding subsequent layers. We formulate necessary conditions for saturation. Numerically, we find layerwise QAOA reaches its maximum overlap at depth $p^*=n$. The addition of coherent dephasing errors to training removes saturation, recovering robustness to layerwise training. This study sheds new light on the performance limitations and prospects of QAOA.

V. Akshay, H. Philathong, M. E. S. Morales et al.

The quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) has rapidly become a cornerstone of contemporary quantum algorithm development. Despite a growing range of applications, only a few results have been developed towards understanding the algorithms ultimate limitations. Here we report that QAOA exhibits a strong dependence on a problem instances constraint to variable ratio$-$this problem density places a limiting restriction on the algorithms capacity to minimize a corresponding objective function (and hence solve optimization problem instances). Such $reachability~deficits$ persist even in the absence of barren plateaus [McClean et al., 2018] and are outside of the recently reported level-1 QAOA limitations [Hastings 2019]. These findings are among the first to determine strong limitations on variational quantum approximate optimization.

H. Philathong, V. Akshay, I. Zacharov et al.

Gibbs sampling is fundamental to a wide range of computer algorithms. Such algorithms are set to be replaced by physics based processors$-$be it quantum or stochastic annealing devices$-$which embed problem instances and evolve a physical system into an ensemble to recover a probability distribution. At a critical constraint to variable ratio, decision problems$-$such as propositional satisfiability$-$appear to statistically exhibit an abrupt transition in required computational resources. This so called, algorithmic or computational phase transition signature, has yet-to-be observed in contemporary physics based processors. We found that the computational phase transition admits a signature in Gibbs' distributions and hence we predict and prescribe the physical observation of this effect. We simulate such an experiment, that when realized experimentally, we believe would represent a milestone in the physical theory of computation.