12.6CVMay 19
Robust Mitigation of Age-Dependent Confounding Effects via Sample-Difficulty DecorrelationNikhil Cherian Kurian, Victor Caquilpan Parra, Abin Shoby et al.
Age dependent performance disparities in medical image classification often arise because age acts as a confounder, linking imaging morphology with disease prevalence. In practice, disparities can manifest as overdiagnosis at ages where disease prevalence is higher and underdiagnosis at ages where prevalence is lower, and can worsen under train test shifts in the age distribution. Conventional mitigation approaches that enforce strict age invariance may suppress diagnostically meaningful information encoded in age. We therefore propose a robust framework that mitigates the effects of age-dependent confounding by targeting spurious age linked trends rather than enforcing invariance. Following a warm-up phase, we characterize sample difficulty and model its age-dependent trends in a label-conditioned manner. We decorrelate age from dominant age difficulty trends using robust, Huber weighted affinity weights, attenuating confounding-driven shortcuts while preserving clinically meaningful, nonlinear age information. We further introduce an Age Coverage Score that scales the decorrelation penalty by minibatch age variance to ensure stable optimization under limited age diversity. Across two radiology datasets, our approach reduces age dependent true and false positive disparities with minimal AUC impact and remains robust to increasing train test age distribution shifts.
4.9CVMay 19
Neuron Incidence Redistribution for Fairness in Medical Image ClassificationAbin Shoby, Lyle John Palmer, Nikhil Cherian Kurian
Deep learning models for medical image classification are susceptible to subgroup performance disparities across demographic attributes such as age, gender, and race. We identify a latent representational mechanism underlying these disparities: in transfer-learned models, the dominant penultimate-layer activation channel under positive predictions is co-activated by both disease-positive samples and privileged demographic groups (male, older patients), producing over-diagnosis; conversely, the dominant channel under negative predictions is co-activated by disadvantaged groups (female, younger patients), producing systematic under-diagnosis. To address this, we propose Neuron Incidence Redistribution (NIR), a lightweight regularization method that penalizes the variance of predicted-probability-weighted mean activations across penultimate-layer neurons, requiring no demographic labels at training time. On HAM10000, TPR disparity drops from 10.81% to 0.93% across age groups and from 12.04% to 0.74% across gender, with a marginal AUC improvement of 0.51 points. On Harvard OCT-RNFL, NIR reduces FPR disparity for race (from 15.68% to 10.66%) and age (from 12.69% to 1.80%), demonstrating that distributing latent disease evidence across the full penultimate layer is a principled and effective strategy for improving demographic fairness in medical AI.
40.5LGMay 19
Worst-Group Equalized Odds Regularization for Multi-Attribute Fair Medical Image ClassificationNikhil Cherian Kurian, Victor Caquilpan Parra, Abin Shoby et al.
Diagnostic performance in medical AI varies systematically across demographic groups, yet subgroup AUC can mask clinically important disparities. At a fixed inference-time operating point, some groups may exhibit over-diagnostic behaviour, characterized by elevated true and false positive rates, while others show under-diagnostic patterns with reduced true and false positive rates. These opposing tendencies can cancel in aggregate AUCs while producing meaningful inequities in clinical decision-making. Motivated by the need to assess and mitigate such disparities at the operating point and across multiple demographic attributes simultaneously, we propose a worst-group equalized-odds margin regularizer. The proposed regularizer explicitly targets subgroup-level deviations on both the true positive and false positive sides at inference. At each update, the method identifies subgroups defined by explicit demographic attributes (e.g., age, sex, and race) that exhibit the most extreme margin deviations and applies a unified penalty, enabling fairness optimization across multiple demographic axes without requiring explicit intersectional constraints. Across two medical imaging datasets in realistic multi-label settings, our method consistently reduces disparities in Equalized Odds and Equalized Opportunity with minimal impact on AUC, preserving diagnostic performance while improving fairness.
CVMar 8
Overthinking Causes Hallucination: Tracing Confounder Propagation in Vision Language ModelsAbin Shoby, Ta Duc Huy, Tuan Dung Nguyen et al.
Vision Language models (VLMs) often hallucinate non-existent objects. Detecting hallucination is analogous to detecting deception: a single final statement is insufficient, one must examine the underlying reasoning process. Yet existing detectors rely mostly on final-layer signals. Attention-based methods assume hallucinated tokens exhibit low attention, while entropy-based ones use final-step uncertainty. Our analysis reveals the opposite: hallucinated objects can exhibit peaked attention due to contextual priors; and models often express high confidence because intermediate layers have already converged to an incorrect hypothesis. We show that the key to hallucination detection lies within the model's thought process, not its final output. By probing decoder layers, we uncover a previously overlooked behavior, overthinking: models repeatedly revise object hypotheses across layers before committing to an incorrect answer. Once the model latches onto a confounded hypothesis, it can propagate through subsequent layers, ultimately causing hallucination. To capture this behavior, we introduce the Overthinking Score, a metric to measure how many competing hypotheses the model entertains and how unstable these hypotheses are across layers. This score significantly improves hallucination detection: 78.9% F1 on MSCOCO and 71.58% on AMBER.