Alexander Semenov

Alexander Semenov, Konstantin Chukharev, Egor Tarasov et al.

In this paper we investigate how to estimate the hardness of Boolean satisfiability (SAT) encodings for the Logical Equivalence Checking problem (LEC). Meaningful estimates of hardness are important in cases when a conventional SAT solver cannot solve a SAT instance in a reasonable time. We show that the hardness of SAT encodings for LEC instances can be estimated \textit{w.r.t.} some SAT partitioning. We also demonstrate the dependence of the accuracy of the resulting estimates on the probabilistic characteristics of a specially defined random variable associated with the considered partitioning. The paper proposes several methods for constructing partitionings, which, when used in practice, allow one to estimate the hardness of SAT encodings for LEC with good accuracy. In the experimental part we propose a class of scalable LEC tests that give extremely complex instances with a relatively small input size $n$ of the considered circuits. For example, for $n = 40$, none of the state-of-the-art SAT solvers can cope with the considered tests in a reasonable time. However, these tests can be solved in parallel using the proposed partitioning methods.

Daniil Chivilikhin, Artem Pavlenko, Alexander Semenov

In the article, within the framework of the Boolean Satisfiability problem (SAT), the problem of estimating the hardness of specific Boolean formulas w.r.t. a specific complete SAT solving algorithm is considered. Based on the well-known Strong Backdoor Set (SBS) concept, we introduce the notion of decomposition hardness (d-hardness). If $B$ is an arbitrary subset of the set of variables occurring in a SAT formula $C$, and $A$ is an arbitrary complete SAT solver , then the d-hardness expresses an estimate of the hardness of $C$ w.r.t. $A$ and $B$. We show that the d-hardness of $C$ w.r.t. a particular $B$ can be expressed in terms of the expected value of a special random variable associated with $A$, $B$, and $C$. For its computational evaluation, algorithms based on the Monte Carlo method can be used. The problem of finding $B$ with the minimum value of d-hardness is formulated as an optimization problem for a pseudo-Boolean function whose values are calculated as a result of a probabilistic experiment. To minimize this function, we use evolutionary algorithms. In the experimental part, we demonstrate the applicability of the concept of d-hardness and the methods of its estimation to solving hard unsatisfiable SAT instances.

Alexander A. Semenov

In the present paper we describe new heuristic technique, which can be applied to the optimization of pseudo-Boolean functions including Black-Box functions. This technique is based on a simple procedure which consists in transition from the optimization problem over Boolean hypercube to the optimization problem of auxiliary function in a specially constructed metric space. It is shown that there is a natural connection between the points of the original Boolean hypercube and points from the new metric space. For the Boolean hypercube with fixed dimension it is possible to construct a number of such metric spaces. The proposed technique can be considered as a special case of Variable Neighborhood Search, which is focused on pseudo-Boolean optimization. Preliminary computational results show high efficiency of the proposed technique on some reasonably hard problems. Also it is shown that the described technique in combination with the well-known (1+1)-Evolutionary Algorithm allows to decrease the upper bound on the runtime of this algorithm for arbitrary pseudo-Boolean functions.

Alexander Semenov, Ilya Otpuschennikov, Irina Gribanova et al.

In the present paper, we propose a technology for translating algorithmic descriptions of discrete functions to SAT. The proposed technology is aimed at applications in algebraic cryptanalysis. We describe how cryptanalysis problems are reduced to SAT in such a way that it should be perceived as natural by the cryptographic community. In~the theoretical part of the paper we justify the main principles of general reduction to SAT for discrete functions from a class containing the majority of functions employed in cryptography. Then, we describe the Transalg software tool developed based on these principles with SAT-based cryptanalysis specifics in mind. We demonstrate the results of applications of Transalg to construction of a number of attacks on various cryptographic functions. Some of the corresponding attacks are state of the art. We compare the functional capabilities of the proposed tool with that of other domain-specific software tools which can be used to reduce cryptanalysis problems to SAT, and also with the CBMC system widely employed in symbolic verification. The paper also presents vast experimental data, obtained using the SAT solvers that took first places at the SAT competitions in the recent several years.

Alexander Semenov, Oleg Zaikin, Ilya Otpuschennikov et al.

Propositional satisfiability (SAT) is at the nucleus of state-of-the-art approaches to a variety of computationally hard problems, one of which is cryptanalysis. Moreover, a number of practical applications of SAT can only be tackled efficiently by identifying and exploiting a subset of formula's variables called backdoor set (or simply backdoors). This paper proposes a new class of backdoor sets for SAT used in the context of cryptographic attacks, namely guess-and-determine attacks. The idea is to identify the best set of backdoor variables subject to a statistically estimated hardness of the guess-and-determine attack using a SAT solver. Experimental results on weakened variants of the renowned encryption algorithms exhibit advantage of the proposed approach compared to the state of the art in terms of the estimated hardness of the resulting guess-and-determine attacks.

Ilya Otpuschennikov, Alexander Semenov, Irina Gribanova et al.

In this paper we propose the technology for constructing propositional encodings of discrete functions. It is aimed at solving inversion problems of considered functions using state-of-the-art SAT solvers. We implemented this technology in the form of the software system called Transalg, and used it to construct SAT encodings for a number of cryptanalysis problems. By applying SAT solvers to these encodings we managed to invert several cryptographic functions. In particular, we used the SAT encodings produced by Transalg to construct the family of two-block MD5 collisions in which the first 10 bytes are zeros. Also we used Transalg encoding for the widely known A5/1 keystream generator to solve several dozen of its cryptanalysis instances in a distributed computing environment. In the paper we compare in detail the functionality of Transalg with that of similar software systems.

Alexander Semenov, Oleg Zaikin, Ilya Otpuschennikov

In this paper we describe the volunteer computing project SAT@home, developed and maintained by us. This project is aimed at solving hard instances of the Boolean satisfiability problem (SAT). We believe that this project can be a useful tool for computational study of inversion problems of some cryptographic functions. In particular we describe a series of experiments performed in SAT@home on the cryptanalysis of the widely known keystream generator A5/1. In all experiments we analyzed one known burst (114 bits) of keystream produced by A5/1. Before the cryptanalysis itself there is a stage on which the partitioning of the original problem to a family of subproblems is carried out. Each of subproblems should be easy enough so that it could be solved in relatively small amount of time by volunteer's PC. We construct such partitioning using the special technique based on the Monte Carlo method and discrete optimization algorithms for special predictive functions. Besides this in the paper we describe the technique for reducing inversion problems of cryptographic functions to SAT.

Stepan Kochemazov, Alexander Semenov

In this paper, we propose an approach for modeling and analysis of a number of phenomena of collective behavior. By collectives we mean multi-agent systems that transition from one state to another at discrete moments of time. The behavior of a member of a collective (agent) is called conforming if the opinion of this agent at current time moment conforms to the opinion of some other agents at the previous time moment. We presume that at each moment of time every agent makes a decision by choosing from the set {0,1} (where 1-decision corresponds to action and 0-decision corresponds to inaction). In our approach we model collective behavior with synchronous Boolean networks. We presume that in a network there can be agents that act at every moment of time. Such agents are called instigators. Also there can be agents that never act. Such agents are called loyalists. Agents that are neither instigators nor loyalists are called simple agents. We study two combinatorial problems. The first problem is to find a disposition of instigators that in several time moments transforms a network from a state where a majority of simple agents are inactive to a state with a majority of active agents. The second problem is to find a disposition of loyalists that returns the network to a state with a majority of inactive agents. Similar problems are studied for networks in which simple agents demonstrate the contrary to conforming behavior that we call anticonforming. We obtained several theoretical results regarding the behavior of collectives of agents with conforming or anticonforming behavior. In computational experiments we solved the described problems for randomly generated networks with several hundred vertices. We reduced corresponding combinatorial problems to the Boolean satisfiability problem (SAT) and used modern SAT solvers to solve the instances obtained.

Ilya Otpuschennikov, Alexander Semenov, Stepan Kochemazov

In this paper we present the Transalg system, designed to produce SAT encodings for discrete functions, written as programs in a specific language. Translation of such programs to SAT is based on propositional encoding methods for formal computing models and on the concept of symbolic execution. We used the Transalg system to make SAT encodings for a number of cryptographic functions.

Alexander Semenov, Oleg Zaikin

This paper proposes a method to estimate the total time required to solve SAT in distributed environments via partitioning approach. It is based on the observation that for some simple forms of problem partitioning one can use the Monte Carlo approach to estimate the time required to solve an original problem. The method proposed is based on an algorithm for searching for partitioning with an optimal solving time estimation. We applied this method to estimate the time required to perform logical cryptanalysis of the widely known stream ciphers A5/1 and Bivium. The paper also describes a volunteer computing project SAT@home aimed at solving hard combinatorial problems reduced to SAT. In this project during several months there were solved 10 problems of logical cryptanalysis of the A5/1 cipher thatcould not be solved using known rainbow tables.