Mehmet Mars Seven

Mehmet Mars Seven

We extend the optimin notion of Ismail (2025) from mixed strategy profiles to correlated distributions. A correlated distribution is evaluated by the worst expected payoff each player can receive when opponents may either obey their private recommendations or make unilateral recommendation-contingent deviations that are strictly profitable under the posterior induced by the distribution. Correlated optimins are Pareto optimal with respect to this vector of guaranteed payoffs. We show that a correlated optimin exists in every finite game. In addition, for every correlated equilibrium, there exists a correlated optimin such that every player's guaranteed payoff is weakly higher than his or her correlated equilibrium payoff. In two-player zero-sum games, correlated optimin coincides with correlated equilibrium and yields the maximin value. Outside zero-sum games, correlated optimin may strictly improve upon all correlated equilibria. We illustrate this with a simple 2x2 game with a unique correlated and coarse correlated equilibrium, in which there exists a correlated optimin that strictly Pareto dominates the equilibrium payoff.

Shaun Hargreaves Heap, Mehmet Mars Seven

We study whether zero-sum decision rules, maximin and minimax, harm agents' interests in positive-sum strategic environments relative to Nash equilibrium behavior or, more generally, than best response behaviour. Contrary to an influential evolutionary view, we give illustrations where maximin serves an agent's interests better than Nash equilibrium behaviour. We also show that these illustration are not atypical or idiosyncratic because, in our main result, the class of such games where a maximin profile strictly Pareto dominates all Nash equilibria has the same cardinality as the class of games in which a Nash equilibrium strictly Pareto dominates all maximin profiles. Thus, neither behavior is generally superior. We further identify additional mechanisms favoring maximin over Nash equilibrium, including coordination failures under multiple equilibria, where maximin can outperform Nash play in realised-pay-off terms. A systematic analysis of strictly ordinal symmetric 3x3 games shows that these effects arise with non-trivial frequency. Our findings, therefore, suggest that the observed rise in zero-sum thinking in many rich countries, when associated with a maximin decision rule, will not be readily displaced through its generation of inferior pay-offs.