Timon Rabczuk

LG
h-index133
22papers
4,175citations
Novelty38%
AI Score43

22 Papers

4.6LGAug 4, 2024Code
Applications of Scientific Machine Learning for the Analysis of Functionally Graded Porous Beams

Mohammad Sadegh Eshaghi, Mostafa Bamdad, Cosmin Anitescu et al.

This study investigates different Scientific Machine Learning (SciML) approaches for the analysis of functionally graded (FG) porous beams and compares them under a new framework. The beam material properties are assumed to vary as an arbitrary continuous function. The methods consider the output of a neural network/operator as an approximation to the displacement fields and derive the equations governing beam behavior based on the continuum formulation. The methods are implemented in the framework and formulated by three approaches: (a) the vector approach leads to a Physics-Informed Neural Network (PINN), (b) the energy approach brings about the Deep Energy Method (DEM), and (c) the data-driven approach, which results in a class of Neural Operator methods. Finally, a neural operator has been trained to predict the response of the porous beam with functionally graded material under any porosity distribution pattern and any arbitrary traction condition. The results are validated with analytical and numerical reference solutions. The data and code accompanying this manuscript will be publicly available at https://github.com/eshaghi-ms/DeepNetBeam.

1.2NAMar 17, 2012
On the application of polynomial and NURBS functions for nonlocal response of low dimensional structures

S. Natarajan, T. Rabczuk, S. Bordas et al.

In this paper, the axial vibration of cracked beams, the free flexural vibrations of nanobeams and plates based on Timoshenko beam theory and first-order shear deformable plate theory, respectively, using Eringen's nonlocal elasticity theory is numerically studied. The field variable is approximated by Lagrange polynomials and non-uniform rational B-splines. The influence of the nonlocal parameter, the beam and the plate aspect ratio and the boundary conditions on the natural frequency is numerically studied. The influence of a crack on axial vibration is also studied. The results obtained from this study are found to be in good agreement with those reported in the literature.

9.4CEMay 24
Data-Driven Structural Health Monitoring of Short Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymer Composites via Multiphysics Phase-Field Simulation

Behrouz Arash, Shadab Zakavati, Quan Wang et al.

Short carbon fiber-reinforced polymer (SCFRP) composites exploit the intrinsic conductivity of the carbon fiber network for self-sensing, yet no predictive model couples their anisotropic, rate-dependent fracture to piezoresistive damage identification. This work presents a finite deformation multiphysics phase-field framework coupling a viscoelastic-viscoplastic constitutive model, an anisotropic crack resistance formulation, and a piezoresistive conductivity model. The three sub-problems are unified through the second-order fiber orientation tensor, which simultaneously defines fiber family directions, crack resistance anisotropy, and principal conduction paths of the carbon fiber network. A damage-coupled conductivity tensor captures both strain-driven geometric-kinematic resistance changes and irreversible network severance driven by the phase-field variable. The framework is coupled to an eight-electrode electrical impedance tomography configuration, and the normalized inter-electrode conductance ratios serve as inputs to a feedforward artificial neural network that infers normalized crack length and mechanical compliance without mechanical sensing. The network achieves R2 = 0.99 on held-out configurations, confirming generalization across the microstructure space. The framework establishes a physics-based, computationally efficient route for real-time structural health monitoring and inverse damage assessment in SCFRP composites.

3.3CENov 6, 2024Code
Energy-based physics-informed neural network for frictionless contact problems under large deformation

Jinshuai Bai, Zhongya Lin, Yizheng Wang et al.

Numerical methods for contact mechanics are of great importance in engineering applications, enabling the prediction and analysis of complex surface interactions under various conditions. In this work, we propose an energy-based physics-informed neural network (PINNs) framework for solving frictionless contact problems under large deformation. Inspired by microscopic Lennard-Jones potential, a surface contact energy is used to describe the contact phenomena. To ensure the robustness of the proposed PINN framework, relaxation, gradual loading and output scaling techniques are introduced. In the numerical examples, the well-known Hertz contact benchmark problem is conducted, demonstrating the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed PINNs framework. Moreover, challenging contact problems with the consideration of geometrical and material nonlinearities are tested. It has been shown that the proposed PINNs framework provides a reliable and powerful tool for nonlinear contact mechanics. More importantly, the proposed PINNs framework exhibits competitive computational efficiency to the commercial FEM software when dealing with those complex contact problems. The codes used in this manuscript are available at https://github.com/JinshuaiBai/energy_PINN_Contact.(The code will be available after acceptance)

8.0SYOct 21, 2024
Artificial intelligence for partial differential equations in computational mechanics: A review

Yizheng Wang, Jinshuai Bai, Zhongya Lin et al.

In recent years, Artificial intelligence (AI) has become ubiquitous, empowering various fields, especially integrating artificial intelligence and traditional science (AI for Science: Artificial intelligence for science), which has attracted widespread attention. In AI for Science, using artificial intelligence algorithms to solve partial differential equations (AI for PDEs: Artificial intelligence for partial differential equations) has become a focal point in computational mechanics. The core of AI for PDEs is the fusion of data and partial differential equations (PDEs), which can solve almost any PDEs. Therefore, this article provides a comprehensive review of the research on AI for PDEs, summarizing the existing algorithms and theories. The article discusses the applications of AI for PDEs in computational mechanics, including solid mechanics, fluid mechanics, and biomechanics. The existing AI for PDEs algorithms include those based on Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs), Deep Energy Methods (DEM), Operator Learning, and Physics-Informed Neural Operator (PINO). AI for PDEs represents a new method of scientific simulation that provides approximate solutions to specific problems using large amounts of data, then fine-tuning according to specific physical laws, avoiding the need to compute from scratch like traditional algorithms. Thus, AI for PDEs is the prototype for future foundation models in computational mechanics, capable of significantly accelerating traditional numerical algorithms.

20.5LGFeb 2, 2025
Transfer Learning in Physics-Informed Neural Networks: Full Fine-Tuning, Lightweight Fine-Tuning, and Low-Rank Adaptation

Yizheng Wang, Jinshuai Bai, Mohammad Sadegh Eshaghi et al.

AI for PDEs has garnered significant attention, particularly Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs). However, PINNs are typically limited to solving specific problems, and any changes in problem conditions necessitate retraining. Therefore, we explore the generalization capability of transfer learning in the strong and energy form of PINNs across different boundary conditions, materials, and geometries. The transfer learning methods we employ include full finetuning, lightweight finetuning, and Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA). The results demonstrate that full finetuning and LoRA can significantly improve convergence speed while providing a slight enhancement in accuracy.

5.1CEMar 18, 2024
A Pretraining-Finetuning Computational Framework for Material Homogenization

Yizheng Wang, Xiang Li, Ziming Yan et al.

Homogenization is a fundamental tool for studying multiscale physical phenomena. Traditional numerical homogenization methods, heavily reliant on finite element analysis, demand significant computational resources, especially for complex geometries, materials, and high-resolution problems. To address these challenges, we propose PreFine-Homo, a novel numerical homogenization framework comprising two phases: pretraining and fine-tuning. In the pretraining phase, a Fourier Neural Operator (FNO) is trained on large datasets to learn the mapping from input geometries and material properties to displacement fields. In the fine-tuning phase, the pretrained predictions serve as initial solutions for iterative algorithms, drastically reducing the number of iterations needed for convergence. The pretraining phase of PreFine-Homo delivers homogenization results up to 1000 times faster than conventional methods, while the fine-tuning phase further enhances accuracy. Moreover, the fine-tuning phase grants PreFine-Homo unlimited generalization capabilities, enabling continuous learning and improvement as data availability increases. We validate PreFine-Homo by predicting the effective elastic tensor for 3D periodic materials, specifically Triply Periodic Minimal Surfaces (TPMS). The results demonstrate that PreFine-Homo achieves high precision, exceptional efficiency, robust learning capabilities, and strong extrapolation ability, establishing it as a powerful tool for multiscale homogenization tasks.

29.3LGJun 16, 2024Code
Kolmogorov Arnold Informed neural network: A physics-informed deep learning framework for solving forward and inverse problems based on Kolmogorov Arnold Networks

Yizheng Wang, Jia Sun, Jinshuai Bai et al.

AI for partial differential equations (PDEs) has garnered significant attention, particularly with the emergence of Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs). The recent advent of Kolmogorov-Arnold Network (KAN) indicates that there is potential to revisit and enhance the previously MLP-based PINNs. Compared to MLPs, KANs offer interpretability and require fewer parameters. PDEs can be described in various forms, such as strong form, energy form, and inverse form. While mathematically equivalent, these forms are not computationally equivalent, making the exploration of different PDE formulations significant in computational physics. Thus, we propose different PDE forms based on KAN instead of MLP, termed Kolmogorov-Arnold-Informed Neural Network (KINN) for solving forward and inverse problems. We systematically compare MLP and KAN in various numerical examples of PDEs, including multi-scale, singularity, stress concentration, nonlinear hyperelasticity, heterogeneous, and complex geometry problems. Our results demonstrate that KINN significantly outperforms MLP regarding accuracy and convergence speed for numerous PDEs in computational solid mechanics, except for the complex geometry problem. This highlights KINN's potential for more efficient and accurate PDE solutions in AI for PDEs.

4.4LGDec 21, 2021
Multigoal-oriented dual-weighted-residual error estimation using deep neural networks

Ayan Chakraborty, Thomas Wick, Xiaoying Zhuang et al.

Deep learning has shown successful application in visual recognition and certain artificial intelligence tasks. Deep learning is also considered as a powerful tool with high flexibility to approximate functions. In the present work, functions with desired properties are devised to approximate the solutions of PDEs. Our approach is based on a posteriori error estimation in which the adjoint problem is solved for the error localization to formulate an error estimator within the framework of neural network. An efficient and easy to implement algorithm is developed to obtain a posteriori error estimate for multiple goal functionals by employing the dual-weighted residual approach, which is followed by the computation of both primal and adjoint solutions using the neural network. The present study shows that such a data-driven model based learning has superior approximation of quantities of interest even with relatively less training data. The novel algorithmic developments are substantiated with numerical test examples. The advantages of using deep neural network over the shallow neural network are demonstrated and the convergence enhancing techniques are also presented

2.4IVNov 19, 2021
Resistance-Time Co-Modulated PointNet for Temporal Super-Resolution Simulation of Blood Vessel Flows

Zhizheng Jiang, Fei Gao, Renshu Gu et al.

In this paper, a novel deep learning framework is proposed for temporal super-resolution simulation of blood vessel flows, in which a high-temporal-resolution time-varying blood vessel flow simulation is generated from a low-temporal-resolution flow simulation result. In our framework, point-cloud is used to represent the complex blood vessel model, resistance-time aided PointNet model is proposed for extracting the time-space features of the time-varying flow field, and finally we can reconstruct the high-accuracy and high-resolution flow field through the Decoder module. In particular, the amplitude loss and the orientation loss of the velocity are proposed from the vector characteristics of the velocity. And the combination of these two metrics constitutes the final loss function for network training. Several examples are given to illustrate the effective and efficiency of the proposed framework for temporal super-resolution simulation of blood vessel flows.

13.4NAFeb 4, 2021
A Deep Collocation Method for the Bending Analysis of Kirchhoff Plate

Hongwei Guo, Xiaoying Zhuang, Timon Rabczuk

In this paper, a deep collocation method (DCM) for thin plate bending problems is proposed. This method takes advantage of computational graphs and backpropagation algorithms involved in deep learning. Besides, the proposed DCM is based on a feedforward deep neural network (DNN) and differs from most previous applications of deep learning for mechanical problems. First, batches of randomly distributed collocation points are initially generated inside the domain and along the boundaries. A loss function is built with the aim that the governing partial differential equations (PDEs) of Kirchhoff plate bending problems, and the boundary/initial conditions are minimised at those collocation points. A combination of optimizers is adopted in the backpropagation process to minimize the loss function so as to obtain the optimal hyperparameters. In Kirchhoff plate bending problems, the C1 continuity requirement poses significant difficulties in traditional mesh-based methods. This can be solved by the proposed DCM, which uses a deep neural network to approximate the continuous transversal deflection, and is proved to be suitable to the bending analysis of Kirchhoff plate of various geometries.

6.5LGOct 9, 2020
Deep Autoencoder based Energy Method for the Bending, Vibration, and Buckling Analysis of Kirchhoff Plates

Xiaoying Zhuang, Hongwei Guo, Naif Alajlan et al.

In this paper, we present a deep autoencoder based energy method (DAEM) for the bending, vibration and buckling analysis of Kirchhoff plates. The DAEM exploits the higher order continuity of the DAEM and integrates a deep autoencoder and the minimum total potential principle in one framework yielding an unsupervised feature learning method. The DAEM is a specific type of feedforward deep neural network (DNN) and can also serve as function approximator. With robust feature extraction capacity, the DAEM can more efficiently identify patterns behind the whole energy system, such as the field variables, natural frequency and critical buckling load factor studied in this paper. The objective function is to minimize the total potential energy. The DAEM performs unsupervised learning based on random generated points inside the physical domain so that the total potential energy is minimized at all points. For vibration and buckling analysis, the loss function is constructed based on Rayleigh's principle and the fundamental frequency and the critical buckling load is extracted. A scaled hyperbolic tangent activation function for the underlying mechanical model is presented which meets the continuity requirement and alleviates the gradient vanishing/explosive problems under bending analysis. The DAEM can be easily implemented and we employed the Pytorch library and the LBFGS optimizer. A comprehensive study of the DAEM configuration is performed for several numerical examples with various geometries, load conditions, and boundary conditions.

9.6LGOct 3, 2020
Analysis of three dimensional potential problems in non-homogeneous media with physics-informed deep collocation method using material transfer learning and sensitivity analysis

Hongwei Guo, Xiaoying Zhuang, Pengwan Chen et al.

In this work, we present a deep collocation method for three dimensional potential problems in nonhomogeneous media. This approach utilizes a physics informed neural network with material transfer learning reducing the solution of the nonhomogeneous partial differential equations to an optimization problem. We tested different cofigurations of the physics informed neural network including smooth activation functions, sampling methods for collocation points generation and combined optimizers. A material transfer learning technique is utilised for nonhomogeneous media with different material gradations and parameters, which enhance the generality and robustness of the proposed method. In order to identify the most influential parameters of the network configuration, we carried out a global sensitivity analysis. Finally, we provide a convergence proof of our DCM. The approach is validated through several benchmark problems, also testing different material variations.

5.0LGOct 3, 2020
Stochastic analysis of heterogeneous porous material with modified neural architecture search (NAS) based physics-informed neural networks using transfer learning

Hongwei Guo, Xiaoying Zhuang, Timon Rabczuk

In this work, a modified neural architecture search method (NAS) based physics-informed deep learning model is presented for stochastic analysis in heterogeneous porous material. Monte Carlo method based on a randomized spectral representation is first employed to construct a stochastic model for simulation of flow through porous media. To solve the governing equations for stochastic groundwater flow problem, we build a modified NAS model based on physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) with transfer learning in this paper that will be able to fit different partial differential equations (PDEs) with less calculation. The performance estimation strategies adopted is constructed from an error estimation model using the method of manufactured solutions. A sensitivity analysis is performed to obtain the prior knowledge of the PINNs model and narrow down the range of parameters for search space and use hyper-parameter optimization algorithms to further determine the values of the parameters. Further the NAS based PINNs model also saves the weights and biases of the most favorable architectures, then used in the fine-tuning process. It is found that the log-conductivity field using Gaussian correlation function will perform much better than exponential correlation case, which is more fitted to the PINNs model and the modified neural architecture search based PINNs model shows a great potential in approximating solutions to PDEs. Moreover, a three dimensional stochastic flow model is built to provide a benchmark to the simulation of groundwater flow in highly heterogeneous aquifers. The NAS model based deep collocation method is verified to be effective and accurate through numerical examples in different dimensions using different manufactured solutions.

1.2LGSep 11, 2020
High correlated variables creator machine: Prediction of the compressive strength of concrete

Aydin Shishegaran, Hessam Varaee, Timon Rabczuk et al.

In this paper, we introduce a novel hybrid model for predicting the compressive strength of concrete using ultrasonic pulse velocity (UPV) and rebound number (RN). First, 516 data from 8 studies of UPV and rebound hammer (RH) tests was collected. Then, high correlated variables creator machine (HVCM) is used to create the new variables that have a better correlation with the output and improve the prediction models. Three single models, including a step-by-step regression (SBSR), gene expression programming (GEP) and an adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system (ANFIS) as well as three hybrid models, i.e. HCVCM-SBSR, HCVCM-GEP and HCVCM-ANFIS, were employed to predict the compressive strength of concrete. The statistical parameters and error terms such as coefficient of determination, root mean square error (RMSE), normalized mean square error (NMSE), fractional bias, the maximum positive and negative errors, and mean absolute percentage error (MAPE), were computed to evaluate and compare the models. The results show that HCVCM-ANFIS can predict the compressive strength of concrete better than all other models. HCVCM improves the accuracy of ANFIS by 5% in the coefficient of determination, 10% in RMSE, 3% in NMSE, 20% in MAPE, and 7% in the maximum negative error.

3.3FLU-DYNDec 20, 2019
Shear Stress Distribution Prediction in Symmetric Compound Channels Using Data Mining and Machine Learning Models

Zohreh Sheikh Khozani, Khabat Khosravi, Mohammadamin Torabi et al.

Shear stress distribution prediction in open channels is of utmost importance in hydraulic structural engineering as it directly affects the design of stable channels. In this study, at first, a series of experimental tests were conducted to assess the shear stress distribution in prismatic compound channels. The shear stress values around the whole wetted perimeter were measured in the compound channel with different floodplain widths also in different flow depths in subcritical and supercritical conditions. A set of, data mining and machine learning models including Random Forest (RF), M5P, Random Committee (RC), KStar and Additive Regression Model (AR) implemented on attained data to predict the shear stress distribution in the compound channel. Results indicated among these five models, RF method indicated the most precise results with the highest R2 value of 0.9. Finally, the most powerful data mining method which studied in this research (RF) compared with two well-known analytical models of Shiono and Knight Method (SKM) and Shannon method to acquire the proposed model functioning in predicting the shear stress distribution. The results showed that the RF model has the best prediction performance compared to SKM and Shannon models.

26.9MLAug 27, 2019
An Energy Approach to the Solution of Partial Differential Equations in Computational Mechanics via Machine Learning: Concepts, Implementation and Applications

Esteban Samaniego, Cosmin Anitescu, Somdatta Goswami et al.

Partial Differential Equations (PDE) are fundamental to model different phenomena in science and engineering mathematically. Solving them is a crucial step towards a precise knowledge of the behaviour of natural and engineered systems. In general, in order to solve PDEs that represent real systems to an acceptable degree, analytical methods are usually not enough. One has to resort to discretization methods. For engineering problems, probably the best known option is the finite element method (FEM). However, powerful alternatives such as mesh-free methods and Isogeometric Analysis (IGA) are also available. The fundamental idea is to approximate the solution of the PDE by means of functions specifically built to have some desirable properties. In this contribution, we explore Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) as an option for approximation. They have shown impressive results in areas such as visual recognition. DNNs are regarded here as function approximation machines. There is great flexibility to define their structure and important advances in the architecture and the efficiency of the algorithms to implement them make DNNs a very interesting alternative to approximate the solution of a PDE. We concentrate in applications that have an interest for Computational Mechanics. Most contributions that have decided to explore this possibility have adopted a collocation strategy. In this contribution, we concentrate in mechanical problems and analyze the energetic format of the PDE. The energy of a mechanical system seems to be the natural loss function for a machine learning method to approach a mechanical problem. As proofs of concept, we deal with several problems and explore the capabilities of the method for applications in engineering.

28.0MLJul 4, 2019
Transfer learning enhanced physics informed neural network for phase-field modeling of fracture

Somdatta Goswami, Cosmin Anitescu, Souvik Chakraborty et al.

We present a new physics informed neural network (PINN) algorithm for solving brittle fracture problems. While most of the PINN algorithms available in the literature minimize the residual of the governing partial differential equation, the proposed approach takes a different path by minimizing the variational energy of the system. Additionally, we modify the neural network output such that the boundary conditions associated with the problem are exactly satisfied. Compared to conventional residual based PINN, the proposed approach has two major advantages. First, the imposition of boundary conditions is relatively simpler and more robust. Second, the order of derivatives present in the functional form of the variational energy is of lower order than in the residual form. Hence, training the network is faster. To compute the total variational energy of the system, an efficient scheme that takes as input a geometry described by spline based CAD model and employs Gauss quadrature rules for numerical integration has been proposed. Moreover, we utilize the concept of transfer learning to obtain the crack path in an efficient manner. The proposed approach is used to solve four fracture mechanics problems. For all the examples, results obtained using the proposed approach match closely with the results available in the literature. For the first two examples, we compare the results obtained using the proposed approach with the conventional residual based neural network results. For both the problems, the proposed approach is found to yield better accuracy compared to conventional residual based PINN algorithms.

4.0NEMay 26, 2019
Particle swarm optimization model to predict scour depth around bridge pier

Shahaboddin Shamshirband, Amir Mosavi, Timon Rabczuk

Scour depth around bridge piers plays a vital role in the safety and stability of the bridges. Existing methods to predict scour depth are mainly based on regression models or black box models in which the first one lacks enough accuracy while the later one does not provide a clear mathematical expression to easily employ it for other situations or cases. Therefore, this paper aims to develop new equations using particle swarm optimization as a metaheuristic approach to predict scour depth around bridge piers. To improve the efficiency of the proposed model, individual equations are derived for laboratory and field data. Moreover, sensitivity analysis is conducted to achieve the most effective parameters in the estimation of scour depth for both experimental and filed data sets. Comparing the results of the proposed model with those of existing regression-based equations reveal the superiority of the proposed method in terms of accuracy and uncertainty. Moreover, the ratio of pier width to flow depth and ratio of d50 (mean particle diameter) to flow depth for the laboratory and field data were recognized as the most effective parameters, respectively. The derived equations can be used as a suitable proxy to estimate scour depth in both experimental and prototype scales.

1.2NAMay 6, 2019
Higher order nonlocal operator method

Huilong Ren, Xiaoying Zhuang, Timon Rabczuk

We extend the nonlocal operator method to higher order scheme by using a higher order Taylor series expansion of the unknown field. Such a higher order scheme improves the original nonlocal operator method proposed by the authors in [A nonlocal operator method for solving partial differential equations], which can only achieve one-order convergence. The higher order nonlocal operator method obtains all partial derivatives with specified maximal order simultaneously without resorting to shape functions. The functional based on the nonlocal operators converts the construction of residual and stiffness matrix into a series of matrix multiplication on the nonlocal operator matrix. Several numerical examples solved by strong form or weak form are presented to show the capabilities of this method.

1.2NAApr 25, 2019
Threshold shift method for reliability-based design optimization

Somdatta Goswami, Souvik Chakraborty, Rajib Chowdhury et al.

We present a novel approach, referred to as the 'threshold shift method' (TSM), for reliability based design optimization (RBDO). The proposed approach is similar in spirit with the sequential optimization and reliability analysis (SORA) method where the RBDO problem is decoupled into an optimization and a reliability analysis problem. However, unlike SORA that utilizes shift-vector to shift the design variables within a constraint (independently), in TSM we propose to shift the threshold of the constraints. We argue that modifying a constraint, either by shifting the design variables (SORA) or by shifting the threshold of the constraints (TSM), influences the other constraints of the system. Therefore, we propose to determine the thresholds for all the constraints by solving a single optimization problem. Additionally, the proposed TSM is equipped with an active-constraint determination scheme. To make the method scalable, a practical algorithm for TSM that utilizes two surrogate models is proposed. Unlike the conventional RBDO methods, the proposed approach has the ability to handle highly non-linear probabilistic constraints. The performance of the proposed approach is examined on six benchmark problems selected from the literature. The proposed approach yields excellent results outperforming other popular methods in literature. As for the computational efficiency, the proposed approach is found to be highly efficient, indicating it's future application to other real-life problems.

1.2NAJul 2, 2017
An improved isogeometric analysis method for trimmed geometries

Jinlan Xu, Ningning Sun, Laixin Shu et al.

Trimming techniques are efficient ways to generate complex geometries in Computer-Aided Design(CAD). In this paper, an improved isogeometric analysis(IGA) method for trimmed geometries is proposed. We will show that the proposed method reduces the numerical error of physical solution by 50% for simple trimmed geometries, and the condition number of stiffness matrix is also decreased. Furthermore, the number of integration elements and integration points involved in the solving process can be significantly reduced compared to previous approaches, drastically improving the computational efficiency for IGA problems on the trimmed geometry. Several examples are illustrated to show the effectiveness of the proposed approach.