LGDec 29, 2024
Diminishing Return of Value Expansion MethodsDaniel Palenicek, Michael Lutter, João Carvalho et al.
Model-based reinforcement learning aims to increase sample efficiency, but the accuracy of dynamics models and the resulting compounding errors are often seen as key limitations. This paper empirically investigates potential sample efficiency gains from improved dynamics models in model-based value expansion methods. Our study reveals two key findings when using oracle dynamics models to eliminate compounding errors. First, longer rollout horizons enhance sample efficiency, but the improvements quickly diminish with each additional expansion step. Second, increased model accuracy only marginally improves sample efficiency compared to learned models with identical horizons. These diminishing returns in sample efficiency are particularly noteworthy when compared to model-free value expansion methods. These model-free algorithms achieve comparable performance without the computational overhead. Our results suggest that the limitation of model-based value expansion methods cannot be attributed to model accuracy. Although higher accuracy is beneficial, even perfect models do not provide unrivaled sample efficiency. Therefore, the bottleneck exists elsewhere. These results challenge the common assumption that model accuracy is the primary constraint in model-based reinforcement learning.
CVJul 18, 2017
Robust Monocular SLAM for Egocentric VideosSuvam Patra, Kartikeya Gupta, Faran Ahmad et al.
Regardless of the tremendous progress, a truly general purpose pipeline for Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM) remains a challenge. We investigate the reported failure of state of the art (SOTA) SLAM techniques on egocentric videos. We find that the dominant 3D rotations, low parallax between successive frames, and primarily forward motion in egocentric videos are the most common causes of failures. The incremental nature of SOTA SLAM, in the presence of unreliable pose and 3D estimates in egocentric videos, with no opportunities for global loop closures, generates drifts and leads to the eventual failures of such techniques. Taking inspiration from batch mode Structure from Motion (SFM) techniques, we propose to solve SLAM as an SFM problem over the sliding temporal windows. This makes the problem well constrained. Further, we propose to initialize the camera poses using 2D rotation averaging, followed by translation averaging before structure estimation using bundle adjustment. This helps in stabilizing the camera poses when 3D estimates are not reliable. We show that the proposed SLAM technique, incorporating the two key ideas works successfully for long, shaky egocentric videos where other SOTA techniques have been reported to fail. Qualitative and quantitative comparisons on publicly available egocentric video datasets validate our results.