An Empirical Study of Catastrophic Forgetting in Large Language Models During Continual Fine-tuningYun Luo, Zhen Yang, Fandong Meng et al. · tsinghua
Catastrophic forgetting (CF) is a phenomenon that occurs in machine learning when a model forgets previously learned information while acquiring new knowledge for achieving a satisfactory performance in downstream tasks. As large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance, it is intriguing to investigate whether CF exists during the continual instruction tuning of LLMs. This study empirically evaluates the forgetting phenomenon in LLMs' knowledge during continual instruction tuning from the perspectives of domain knowledge, reasoning, and reading comprehension. The experiments reveal that catastrophic forgetting is generally observed in LLMs ranging from 1b to 7b parameters. Surprisingly, as the model scale increases, the severity of forgetting intensifies in such a model sale range which may result from the much significant initial performance in the larger LLM. Comparing the decoder-only model BLOOMZ with the encoder-decoder model mT0, BLOOMZ exhibits less forgetting and retains more knowledge. Interestingly, we also observe that LLMs can mitigate language biases, such as gender bias, during continual fine-tuning. Furthermore, our findings indicate that general instruction tuning can help alleviate the forgetting phenomenon in LLMs during subsequent fine-tuning.
Improving (Dis)agreement Detection with Inductive Social Relation Information From Comment-Reply InteractionsYun Luo, Zihan Liu, Stan Z. Li et al.
(Dis)agreement detection aims to identify the authors' attitudes or positions (\textit{agree, disagree, neutral}) towards a specific text. It is limited for existing methods merely using textual information for identifying (dis)agreements, especially for cross-domain settings. Social relation information can play an assistant role in the (dis)agreement task besides textual information. We propose a novel method to extract such relation information from (dis)agreement data into an inductive social relation graph, merely using the comment-reply pairs without any additional platform-specific information. The inductive social relation globally considers the historical discussion and the relation between authors. Textual information based on a pre-trained language model and social relation information encoded by pre-trained RGCN are jointly considered for (dis)agreement detection. Experimental results show that our model achieves state-of-the-art performance for both the in-domain and cross-domain tasks on the benchmark -- DEBAGREEMENT. We find social relations can boost the performance of the (dis)agreement detection model, especially for the long-token comment-reply pairs, demonstrating the effectiveness of the social relation graph. We also explore the effect of the knowledge graph embedding methods, the information fusing method, and the time interval in constructing the social relation graph, which shows the effectiveness of our model.
2.6CLApr 14, 2022
Challenges for Open-domain Targeted Sentiment AnalysisYun Luo, Hongjie Cai, Linyi Yang et al.
Since previous studies on open-domain targeted sentiment analysis are limited in dataset domain variety and sentence level, we propose a novel dataset consisting of 6,013 human-labeled data to extend the data domains in topics of interest and document level. Furthermore, we offer a nested target annotation schema to extract the complete sentiment information in documents, boosting the practicality and effectiveness of open-domain targeted sentiment analysis. Moreover, we leverage the pre-trained model BART in a sequence-to-sequence generation method for the task. Benchmark results show that there exists large room for improvement of open-domain targeted sentiment analysis. Meanwhile, experiments have shown that challenges remain in the effective use of open-domain data, long documents, the complexity of target structure, and domain variances.
Towards Reasonable Budget Allocation in Untargeted Graph Structure Attacks via Gradient DebiasZihan Liu, Yun Luo, Lirong Wu et al.
It has become cognitive inertia to employ cross-entropy loss function in classification related tasks. In the untargeted attacks on graph structure, the gradients derived from the attack objective are the attacker's basis for evaluating a perturbation scheme. Previous methods use negative cross-entropy loss as the attack objective in attacking node-level classification models. However, the suitability of the cross-entropy function for constructing the untargeted attack objective has yet been discussed in previous works. This paper argues about the previous unreasonable attack objective from the perspective of budget allocation. We demonstrate theoretically and empirically that negative cross-entropy tends to produce more significant gradients from nodes with lower confidence in the labeled classes, even if the predicted classes of these nodes have been misled. To free up these inefficient attack budgets, we propose a simple attack model for untargeted attacks on graph structure based on a novel attack objective which generates unweighted gradients on graph structures that are not affected by the node confidence. By conducting experiments in gray-box poisoning attack scenarios, we demonstrate that a reasonable budget allocation can significantly improve the effectiveness of gradient-based edge perturbations without any extra hyper-parameter.
Are Gradients on Graph Structure Reliable in Gray-box Attacks?Zihan Liu, Yun Luo, Lirong Wu et al.
Graph edge perturbations are dedicated to damaging the prediction of graph neural networks by modifying the graph structure. Previous gray-box attackers employ gradients from the surrogate model to locate the vulnerable edges to perturb the graph structure. However, unreliability exists in gradients on graph structures, which is rarely studied by previous works. In this paper, we discuss and analyze the errors caused by the unreliability of the structural gradients. These errors arise from rough gradient usage due to the discreteness of the graph structure and from the unreliability in the meta-gradient on the graph structure. In order to address these problems, we propose a novel attack model with methods to reduce the errors inside the structural gradients. We propose edge discrete sampling to select the edge perturbations associated with hierarchical candidate selection to ensure computational efficiency. In addition, semantic invariance and momentum gradient ensemble are proposed to address the gradient fluctuation on semantic-augmented graphs and the instability of the surrogate model. Experiments are conducted in untargeted gray-box poisoning scenarios and demonstrate the improvement in the performance of our approach.
4.6LGAug 26, 2022
What Does the Gradient Tell When Attacking the Graph StructureZihan Liu, Ge Wang, Yun Luo et al.
Recent research has revealed that Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are susceptible to adversarial attacks targeting the graph structure. A malicious attacker can manipulate a limited number of edges, given the training labels, to impair the victim model's performance. Previous empirical studies indicate that gradient-based attackers tend to add edges rather than remove them. In this paper, we present a theoretical demonstration revealing that attackers tend to increase inter-class edges due to the message passing mechanism of GNNs, which explains some previous empirical observations. By connecting dissimilar nodes, attackers can more effectively corrupt node features, making such attacks more advantageous. However, we demonstrate that the inherent smoothness of GNN's message passing tends to blur node dissimilarity in the feature space, leading to the loss of crucial information during the forward process. To address this issue, we propose a novel surrogate model with multi-level propagation that preserves the node dissimilarity information. This model parallelizes the propagation of unaggregated raw features and multi-hop aggregated features, while introducing batch normalization to enhance the dissimilarity in node representations and counteract the smoothness resulting from topological aggregation. Our experiments show significant improvement with our approach.Furthermore, both theoretical and experimental evidence suggest that adding inter-class edges constitutes an easily observable attack pattern. We propose an innovative attack loss that balances attack effectiveness and imperceptibility, sacrificing some attack effectiveness to attain greater imperceptibility. We also provide experiments to validate the compromise performance achieved through this attack loss.
Exploiting Sentiment and Common Sense for Zero-shot Stance DetectionYun Luo, Zihan Liu, Yuefeng Shi et al.
The stance detection task aims to classify the stance toward given documents and topics. Since the topics can be implicit in documents and unseen in training data for zero-shot settings, we propose to boost the transferability of the stance detection model by using sentiment and commonsense knowledge, which are seldom considered in previous studies. Our model includes a graph autoencoder module to obtain commonsense knowledge and a stance detection module with sentiment and commonsense. Experimental results show that our model outperforms the state-of-the-art methods on the zero-shot and few-shot benchmark dataset--VAST. Meanwhile, ablation studies prove the significance of each module in our model. Analysis of the relations between sentiment, common sense, and stance indicates the effectiveness of sentiment and common sense.
Mere Contrastive Learning for Cross-Domain Sentiment AnalysisYun Luo, Fang Guo, Zihan Liu et al.
Cross-domain sentiment analysis aims to predict the sentiment of texts in the target domain using the model trained on the source domain to cope with the scarcity of labeled data. Previous studies are mostly cross-entropy-based methods for the task, which suffer from instability and poor generalization. In this paper, we explore contrastive learning on the cross-domain sentiment analysis task. We propose a modified contrastive objective with in-batch negative samples so that the sentence representations from the same class will be pushed close while those from the different classes become further apart in the latent space. Experiments on two widely used datasets show that our model can achieve state-of-the-art performance in both cross-domain and multi-domain sentiment analysis tasks. Meanwhile, visualizations demonstrate the effectiveness of transferring knowledge learned in the source domain to the target domain and the adversarial test verifies the robustness of our model.
RefuteBench 2.0 -- Agentic Benchmark for Dynamic Evaluation of LLM Responses to Refutation InstructionJianhao Yan, Yun Luo, Yue Zhang · tencent-ai, tsinghua
In the multi-turn interaction schema, large language models (LLMs) can leverage user feedback to enhance the quality and relevance of their responses. However, evaluating an LLM's ability to incorporate user refutation feedback is crucial yet challenging. In this study, we introduce RefuteBench 2.0, which significantly extends the original RefuteBench by incorporating LLM agents as refuters and evaluators, which allows for flexible and comprehensive assessment. We design both transient and persistent refutation instructions with different validity periods. Meta-evaluation shows that the LLM-based refuter could generate more human-like refutations and the evaluators could assign scores with high correlation with humans. Experimental results of various LLMs show that current models could effectively satisfy the refutation but fail to memorize the refutation information. Interestingly, we also observe that the performance of the initial task decreases as the refutations increase. Analysis of the attention scores further shows a potential weakness of current LLMs: they struggle to retain and correctly use previous information during long context dialogues. https://github.com/ElliottYan/RefuteBench-2.0
MCRanker: Generating Diverse Criteria On-the-Fly to Improve Point-wise LLM RankersFang Guo, Wenyu Li, Honglei Zhuang et al. · deepmind
The most recent pointwise Large Language Model (LLM) rankers have achieved remarkable ranking results. However, these rankers are hindered by two major drawbacks: (1) they fail to follow a standardized comparison guidance during the ranking process, and (2) they struggle with comprehensive considerations when dealing with complicated passages. To address these shortcomings, we propose to build a ranker that generates ranking scores based on a set of criteria from various perspectives. These criteria are intended to direct each perspective in providing a distinct yet synergistic evaluation. Our research, which examines eight datasets from the BEIR benchmark demonstrates that incorporating this multi-perspective criteria ensemble approach markedly enhanced the performance of pointwise LLM rankers.
7.7LGMay 20, 2023
Mitigating Catastrophic Forgetting in Task-Incremental Continual Learning with Adaptive Classification CriterionYun Luo, Xiaotian Lin, Zhen Yang et al.
Task-incremental continual learning refers to continually training a model in a sequence of tasks while overcoming the problem of catastrophic forgetting (CF). The issue arrives for the reason that the learned representations are forgotten for learning new tasks, and the decision boundary is destructed. Previous studies mostly consider how to recover the representations of learned tasks. It is seldom considered to adapt the decision boundary for new representations and in this paper we propose a Supervised Contrastive learning framework with adaptive classification criterion for Continual Learning (SCCL), In our method, a contrastive loss is used to directly learn representations for different tasks and a limited number of data samples are saved as the classification criterion. During inference, the saved data samples are fed into the current model to obtain updated representations, and a k Nearest Neighbour module is used for classification. In this way, the extensible model can solve the learned tasks with adaptive criteria of saved samples. To mitigate CF, we further use an instance-wise relation distillation regularization term and a memory replay module to maintain the information of previous tasks. Experiments show that SCCL achieves state-of-the-art performance and has a stronger ability to overcome CF compared with the classification baselines.
7.6CLMay 10, 2023
Investigating Forgetting in Pre-Trained Representations Through Continual LearningYun Luo, Zhen Yang, Xuefeng Bai et al.
Representation forgetting refers to the drift of contextualized representations during continual training. Intuitively, the representation forgetting can influence the general knowledge stored in pre-trained language models (LMs), but the concrete effect is still unclear. In this paper, we study the effect of representation forgetting on the generality of pre-trained language models, i.e. the potential capability for tackling future downstream tasks. Specifically, we design three metrics, including overall generality destruction (GD), syntactic knowledge forgetting (SynF), and semantic knowledge forgetting (SemF), to measure the evolution of general knowledge in continual learning. With extensive experiments, we find that the generality is destructed in various pre-trained LMs, and syntactic and semantic knowledge is forgotten through continual learning. Based on our experiments and analysis, we further get two insights into alleviating general knowledge forgetting: 1) training on general linguistic tasks at first can mitigate general knowledge forgetting; 2) the hybrid continual learning method can mitigate the generality destruction and maintain more general knowledge compared with those only considering rehearsal or regularization.