Benchmarking PtO and PnO Methods in the Predictive Combinatorial Optimization RegimeHaoyu Geng, Hang Ruan, Runzhong Wang et al.
Predictive combinatorial optimization, where the parameters of combinatorial optimization (CO) are unknown at the decision-making time, is the precise modeling of many real-world applications, including energy cost-aware scheduling and budget allocation on advertising. Tackling such a problem usually involves a prediction model and a CO solver. These two modules are integrated into the predictive CO pipeline following two design principles: "Predict-then-Optimize (PtO)", which learns predictions by supervised training and subsequently solves CO using predicted coefficients, while the other, named "Predict-and-Optimize (PnO)", directly optimizes towards the ultimate decision quality and claims to yield better decisions than traditional PtO approaches. However, there lacks a systematic benchmark of both approaches, including the specific design choices at the module level, as well as an evaluation dataset that covers representative real-world scenarios. To this end, we develop a modular framework to benchmark 11 existing PtO/PnO methods on 8 problems, including a new industrial dataset for combinatorial advertising that will be released. Our study shows that PnO approaches are better than PtO on 7 out of 8 benchmarks, but there is no silver bullet found for the specific design choices of PnO. A comprehensive categorization of current approaches and integration of typical scenarios are provided under a unified benchmark. Therefore, this paper could serve as a comprehensive benchmark for future PnO approach development and also offer fast prototyping for application-focused development. The code is available at https://github.com/Thinklab-SJTU/PredictiveCO-Benchmark.
18.2AIJan 13, 2024
Distance-aware Attention Reshaping: Enhance Generalization of Neural Solver for Large-scale Vehicle Routing ProblemsYang Wang, Ya-Hui Jia, Wei-Neng Chen et al.
Neural solvers based on attention mechanism have demonstrated remarkable effectiveness in solving vehicle routing problems. However, in the generalization process from small scale to large scale, we find a phenomenon of the dispersion of attention scores in existing neural solvers, which leads to poor performance. To address this issue, this paper proposes a distance-aware attention reshaping method, assisting neural solvers in solving large-scale vehicle routing problems. Specifically, without the need for additional training, we utilize the Euclidean distance information between current nodes to adjust attention scores. This enables a neural solver trained on small-scale instances to make rational choices when solving a large-scale problem. Experimental results show that the proposed method significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art neural solvers on the large-scale CVRPLib dataset.
6.3IRFeb 5, 2025
Beyond Self-Consistency: Loss-Balanced Perturbation-Based Regularization Improves Industrial-Scale Ads RankingIlqar Ramazanli, Hamid Eghbalzadeh, Xiaoyi Liu et al.
Perturbation-based regularization techniques address many challenges in industrial-scale large models, particularly with sparse labels, and emphasize consistency and invariance for perturbation in model predictions. One of the popular regularization techniques has been various forms of self-consistency, which involve making small modifications to input data while preserving contextual information and enforcing similar predictions through auxiliary loss functions. In this work, we explore the first successful application of perturbation-based regularization algorithms in large-scale ads ranking models, and further propose a novel regularization algorithm, namely, Loss-Balanced Small Perturbation Regularization (LSPR) that can be used in potentially any deep learning model. We have successfully demonstrate that both Self-Consistency Regularization approaches (SCR) and LSPR are scalable and can improve ads delivery systems. By conducting industrial-scale experiments, and numerical analysis, we additionally show that our proposed LSPR, performs consistently better compared to SCR, across various groups and signal availability setups. Finally, we report a successful application of the proposed LSPR in a billion-scale industrial ranking system, which to the best of our knowledge, is the first of its kind, and it is specially designed to address the various scalability challenges (e.g, various surfaces, geological locations, clients and so on) as we will mention in this paper.