CVSep 21, 2022
USC: Uncompromising Spatial Constraints for Safety-Oriented 3D Object Detectors in Autonomous DrivingBrian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Chih-Hong Cheng, Hasan Esen et al.
In this work, we consider the safety-oriented performance of 3D object detectors in autonomous driving contexts. Specifically, despite impressive results shown by the mass literature, developers often find it hard to ensure the safe deployment of these learning-based perception models. Attributing the challenge to the lack of safety-oriented metrics, we hereby present uncompromising spatial constraints (USC), which characterize a simple yet important localization requirement demanding the predictions to fully cover the objects when seen from the autonomous vehicle. The constraints, as we formulate using the perspective and bird's-eye views, can be naturally reflected by quantitative measures, such that having an object detector with a higher score implies a lower risk of collision. Finally, beyond model evaluation, we incorporate the quantitative measures into common loss functions to enable safety-oriented fine-tuning for existing models. With experiments using the nuScenes dataset and a closed-loop simulation, our work demonstrates such considerations of safety notions at the perception level not only improve model performances beyond accuracy but also allow for a more direct linkage to actual system safety.
SEFeb 23
Workflow-Level Design Principles for Trustworthy GenAI in Automotive System EngineeringChih-Hong Cheng, Brian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Adam Molin et al.
The adoption of large language models in safety-critical system engineering is constrained by trustworthiness, traceability, and alignment with established verification practices. We propose workflow-level design principles for trustworthy GenAI integration and demonstrate them in an end-to-end automotive pipeline, from requirement delta identification to SysML v2 architecture update and re-testing. First, we show that monolithic ("big-bang") prompting misses critical changes in large specifications, while section-wise decomposition with diversity sampling and lightweight NLP sanity checks improves completeness and correctness. Then, we propagate requirement deltas into SysML v2 models and validate updates via compilation and static analysis. Additionally, we ensure traceable regression testing by generating test cases through explicit mappings from specification variables to architectural ports and states, providing practical safeguards for GenAI used in safety-critical automotive engineering.
26.7CVApr 2
Safety-Aligned 3D Object Detection: Single-Vehicle, Cooperative, and End-to-End PerspectivesBrian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Chih-Hong Cheng, Hasan Esen et al.
Perception plays a central role in connected and autonomous vehicles (CAVs), underpinning not only conventional modular driving stacks, but also cooperative perception systems and recent end-to-end driving models. While deep learning has greatly improved perception performance, its statistical nature makes perfect predictions difficult to attain. Meanwhile, standard training objectives and evaluation benchmarks treat all perception errors equally, even though only a subset is safety-critical. In this paper, we investigate safety-aligned evaluation and optimization for 3D object detection that explicitly characterize high-impact errors. Building on our previously proposed safety-oriented metric, NDS-USC, and safety-aware loss function, EC-IoU, we make three contributions. First, we present an expanded study of single-vehicle 3D object detection models across diverse neural network architectures and sensing modalities, showing that gains under standard metrics such as mAP and NDS may not translate to safety-oriented criteria represented by NDS-USC. With EC-IoU, we reaffirm the benefit of safety-aware fine-tuning for improving safety-critical detection performance. Second, we conduct an ego-centric, safety-oriented evaluation of AV-infrastructure cooperative object detection models, underscoring its superiority over vehicle-only models and demonstrating a safety impact analysis that illustrates the potential contribution of cooperative models to "Vision Zero." Third, we integrate EC-IoU into SparseDrive and show that safety-aware perception hardening can reduce collision rate by nearly 30% and improve system-level safety directly in an end-to-end perception-to-planning framework. Overall, our results indicate that safety-aligned perception evaluation and optimization offer a practical path toward enhancing CAV safety across single-vehicle, cooperative, and end-to-end autonomy settings.
SESep 28, 2023
Simulation-based Safety Assurance for an AVP System incorporating Learning-Enabled ComponentsHasan Esen, Brian Hsuan-Cheng Liao
There have been major developments in Automated Driving (AD) and Driving Assist Systems (ADAS) in recent years. However, their safety assurance, thus methodologies for testing, verification and validation AD/ADAS safety-critical applications remain as one the main challenges. Inevitably AI also penetrates into AD/ADAS applications, such as object detection. Despite important benefits, adoption of such learned-enabled components and systems in safety-critical scenarios causes that conventional testing approaches (e.g., distance-based testing in automotive) quickly become infeasible. Similarly, safety engineering approaches usually assume model-based components and do not handle learning-enabled ones well. The authors have participated in the public-funded project FOCETA , and developed an Automated Valet Parking (AVP) use case. As the nature of the baseline implementation is imperfect, it offers a space for continuous improvement based on modelling, verification, validation, and monitoring techniques. In this publication, we explain the simulation-based development platform that is designed to verify and validate safety-critical learning-enabled systems in continuous engineering loops.
SEMar 4, 2024
Towards Continuous Assurance Case Creation for ADS with the Evidential Tool BusLev Sorokin, Radouane Bouchekir, Tewodros A. Beyene et al.
An assurance case has become an integral component for the certification of safety-critical systems. While manually defining assurance case patterns can be not avoided, system-specific instantiations of assurance case patterns are both costly and time-consuming. It becomes especially complex to maintain an assurance case for a system when the requirements of the System-Under-Assurance change, or an assurance claim becomes invalid due to, e.g., degradation of a systems component, as common when deploying learning-enabled components. In this paper, we report on our preliminary experience leveraging the tool integration framework Evidential Tool Bus (ETB) for the construction and continuous maintenance of an assurance case from a predefined assurance case pattern. Specifically, we demonstrate the assurance process on an industrial Automated Valet Parking system from the automotive domain. We present the formalization of the provided assurance case pattern in the ETB processable logical specification language of workflows. Our findings show that ETB is able to create and maintain evidence required for the construction of an assurance case.
CVMar 20, 2024
EC-IoU: Orienting Safety for Object Detectors via Ego-Centric Intersection-over-UnionBrian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Chih-Hong Cheng, Hasan Esen et al.
This paper presents Ego-Centric Intersection-over-Union (EC-IoU), addressing the limitation of the standard IoU measure in characterizing safety-related performance for object detectors in navigating contexts. Concretely, we propose a weighting mechanism to refine IoU, allowing it to assign a higher score to a prediction that covers closer points of a ground-truth object from the ego agent's perspective. The proposed EC-IoU measure can be used in typical evaluation processes to select object detectors with better safety-related performance for downstream tasks. It can also be integrated into common loss functions for model fine-tuning. While geared towards safety, our experiment with the KITTI dataset demonstrates the performance of a model trained on EC-IoU can be better than that of a variant trained on IoU in terms of mean Average Precision as well.
RONov 9, 2024
FuzzRisk: Online Collision Risk Estimation for Autonomous Vehicles based on Depth-Aware Object Detection via Fuzzy InferenceBrian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Yingjie Xu, Chih-Hong Cheng et al.
This paper presents a novel monitoring framework that infers the level of collision risk for autonomous vehicles (AVs) based on their object detection performance. The framework takes two sets of predictions from different algorithms and associates their inconsistencies with the collision risk via fuzzy inference. The first set of predictions is obtained by retrieving safety-critical 2.5D objects from a depth map, and the second set comes from the ordinary AV's 3D object detector. We experimentally validate that, based on Intersection-over-Union (IoU) and a depth discrepancy measure, the inconsistencies between the two sets of predictions strongly correlate to the error of the 3D object detector against ground truths. This correlation allows us to construct a fuzzy inference system and map the inconsistency measures to an AV collision risk indicator. In particular, we optimize the fuzzy inference system towards an existing offline metric that matches AV collision rates well. Lastly, we validate our monitor's capability to produce relevant risk estimates with the large-scale nuScenes dataset and demonstrate that it can safeguard an AV in closed-loop simulations.
LGFeb 8, 2022
Are Transformers More Robust? Towards Exact Robustness Verification for TransformersBrian Hsuan-Cheng Liao, Chih-Hong Cheng, Hasan Esen et al.
As an emerging type of Neural Networks (NNs), Transformers are used in many domains ranging from Natural Language Processing to Autonomous Driving. In this paper, we study the robustness problem of Transformers, a key characteristic as low robustness may cause safety concerns. Specifically, we focus on Sparsemax-based Transformers and reduce the finding of their maximum robustness to a Mixed Integer Quadratically Constrained Programming (MIQCP) problem. We also design two pre-processing heuristics that can be embedded in the MIQCP encoding and substantially accelerate its solving. We then conduct experiments using the application of Land Departure Warning to compare the robustness of Sparsemax-based Transformers against that of the more conventional Multi-Layer-Perceptron (MLP) NNs. To our surprise, Transformers are not necessarily more robust, leading to profound considerations in selecting appropriate NN architectures for safety-critical domain applications.