Brian D. O. Anderson

Shaoshuai Mou, A. Stephen Morse, Mohamed Ali Belabbas et al.

By an undirected rigid formation of mobile autonomous agents is meant a formation based on graph rigidity in which each pair of "neighboring" agents is responsible for maintaining a prescribed target distance between them. In a recent paper a systematic method was proposed for devising gradient control laws for asymptotically stabilizing a large class of rigid, undirected formations in two dimensional space assuming all agents are described by kinematic point models. The aim of this paper is to explain what happens to such formations if neighboring agents have slightly different understandings of what the desired distance between them is supposed to be or equivalently if neighboring agents have differing estimates of what the actual distance between them is. In either case, what one would expect would be a gradual distortion of the formation from its target shape as discrepancies in desired or sensed distances increase. While this is observed for the gradient laws in question, something else quite unexpected happens at the same time. It is shown that for any rigidity-based, undirected formation of this type which is comprised of three or more agents, that if some neighboring agents have slightly different understandings of what the desired distances between them are suppose to be, then almost for certain, the trajectory of the resulting distorted but rigid formation will converge exponentially fast to a closed circular orbit in two-dimensional space which is traversed periodically at a constant angular speed.

Zhiyong Sun, Myoung-Chul Park, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

Most rigid formation controllers reported in the literature aim to only stabilize a rigid formation shape, while the formation orientation is not controlled. This paper studies the problem of controlling rigid formations with prescribed orientations in both 2-D and 3-D spaces. The proposed controllers involve the commonly-used gradient descent control for shape stabilization, and an additional term to control the directions of certain relative position vectors associated with certain chosen agents. In this control framework, we show the minimal number of agents which should have knowledge of a global coordinate system (2 agents for a 2-D rigid formation and 3 agents for a 3-D rigid formation), while all other agents do not require any global coordinate knowledge or any coordinate frame alignment to implement the proposed control. The exponential convergence to the desired rigid shape and formation orientation is also proved. Typical simulation examples are shown to support the analysis and performance of the proposed formation controllers.

Mengbin Ye, Minh Hoang Trinh, Young-Hun Lim et al.

In this paper, and inspired by the recent discrete-time model in [1,2], we study two continuous-time opinion dynamics models (Model 1 and Model 2) where the individuals discuss opinions on multiple logically interdependent topics. The logical interdependence between the different topics is captured by a `logic' matrix, which is distinct from the Laplacian matrix capturing interactions between individuals. For each of Model 1 and Model 2, we obtain a necessary and sufficient condition for the network to reach to a consensus on each separate topic. The condition on Model 1 involves a combination of the eigenvalues of the logic matrix and Laplacian matrix, whereas the condition on Model 2 requires only separate conditions on the logic matrix and Laplacian matrix. Further investigations of Model 1 yields two sufficient conditions for consensus, and allow us to conclude that one way to guarantee a consensus is to reduce the rate of interaction between individuals exchanging opinions. By placing further restrictions on the logic matrix, we also establish a set of Laplacian matrices which guarantee consensus for Model 1. The two models are also expanded to include stubborn individuals, who remain attached to their initial opinions. Sufficient conditions are obtained for guaranteeing convergence of the opinion dynamics system, with the final opinions generally being at a persistent disagreement. Simulations are provided to illustrate the results.

Yang Liu, Christian Lageman, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

We study the approach to obtaining least squares solutions to systems of linear algebraic equations over networks by using distributed algorithms. Each node has access to one of the linear equations and holds a dynamic state. The aim for the node states is to reach a consensus as a least squares solution of the linear equations by exchanging their states with neighbors over an underlying interaction graph. A continuous-time distributed least squares solver over networks is developed in the form of the famous Arrow-Hurwicz-Uzawa flow. A necessary and sufficient condition is established on the graph Laplacian for the continuous-time distributed algorithm to give the least squares solution in the limit, with an exponentially fast convergence rate. The feasibility of different fundamental graphs is discussed including path graph, star graph, etc. Moreover, a discrete-time distributed algorithm is developed by Euler's method, converging exponentially to the least squares solution at the node states with suitable step size and graph conditions. The exponential convergence rate for both the continuous-time and discrete-time algorithms under the established conditions is confirmed by numerical examples. Finally, we investigate the performance of the proposed flow under switching networks, and surprisingly, switching networks at high switching frequencies can lead to approximate least square solvers even if all graphs in the switching signal fail to do so in the absence of structure switching.

Yang Liu, Youcheng Lou, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

This paper presents a first-order {distributed continuous-time algorithm} for computing the least-squares solution to a linear equation over networks. Given the uniqueness of the solution, with nonintegrable and diminishing step size, convergence results are provided for fixed graphs. The exact rate of convergence is also established for various types of step size choices falling into that category. For the case where non-unique solutions exist, convergence to one such solution is proved for constantly connected switching graphs with square integrable step size, and for uniformly jointly connected switching graphs under the boundedness assumption on system states. Validation of the results and illustration of the impact of step size on the convergence speed are made using a few numerical examples.

Baoqi Huang, Tao Li, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

In this paper, we study performance limits of sensor localization from a novel perspective. Specifically, we consider the Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB) in single-hop sensor localization using measurements from received signal strength (RSS), time of arrival (TOA) and bearing, respectively, but differently from the existing work, we statistically analyze the trace of the associated CRLB matrix (i.e. as a scalar metric for performance limits of sensor localization) by assuming anchor locations are random. By the Central Limit Theorems for $U$-statistics, we show that as the number of the anchors increases, this scalar metric is asymptotically normal in the RSS/bearing case, and converges to a random variable which is an affine transformation of a chi-square random variable of degree 2 in the TOA case. Moreover, we provide formulas quantitatively describing the relationship among the mean and standard deviation of the scalar metric, the number of the anchors, the parameters of communication channels, the noise statistics in measurements and the spatial distribution of the anchors. These formulas, though asymptotic in the number of the anchors, in many cases turn out to be remarkably accurate in predicting performance limits, even if the number is small. Simulations are carried out to confirm our results.

Myoung-Chul Park, Zhiyong Sun, Minh Hoang Trinh et al.

In this paper, we propose a distance-based formation control strategy that can enable four mobile agents, which are modelled by a group of single-integrators, to achieve the desired formation shape specified by using six consistent inter-agent distances in a 2-dimensional space. The control law is closely related to a gradient-based control law formed from a potential function reflecting the error between the actual inter-agent distances and the desired inter-agent distances. There are already control strategies achieving the same objective in a distance-based control manner in the literature, but the results do not yet include a global as opposed to local stability analysis. We propose a control strategy modified from the existing gradient-based control law so that we can achieve almost global convergence to the desired formation shape, and the control law uses known properties for an associated formation shape control problem involving a four-agent tetrahedron formation in 3-dimensional space. Simulation results verifying our analysis are also presented.

Bomin Jiang, Zhiyong Sun, Brian D. O. Anderson

Most current results on coverage control using mobile sensors require that one partitioned cell is the sole responsibility of one sensor. In this paper, we consider a class of generalized Voronoi coverage control problems by using higher order Voronoi partitions, motivated by applications that more than one senor is required to monitor and cover onecell. We introduce a framework depending on a coverage performance function incorporating higher order Voronoi cells and then design a gradient-based controller which allows the multi-sensor system to achieve a local equilibrium in a distributed manner. In addition, we provide a number of real world scenarios where our framework can be applied. Simulation results are also provided to show the controller performance.

Toshiharu Sugie, Brian D. O. Anderson, Zhiyong Sun et al.

This paper considers a formation shape control problem for point agents in a two-dimensional ambient space, where the control is distributed, is based on achieving desired distances between nominated agent pairs, and avoids the possibility of reflection ambiguities. This has potential applications for large-scale multi-agent systems having simple information exchange structure. One solution to this type of problem, applicable to formations with just three or four agents, was recently given by considering a potential function which consists of both distance error and signed triangle area terms. However, it seems to be challenging to apply it to formations with more than four agents. This paper shows a hierarchical control strategy which can be applicable to any number of agents based on the above type of potential function and a formation shaping incorporating a grouping of equilateral triangles, so that all controlled distances are in fact the same. A key analytical result and some numerical results are shown to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.

Lili Wang, Ji Liu, A. Stephen Morse et al.

A simply structured distributed observer is described for estimating the state of a discrete-time, jointly observable, input-free, linear system whose sensed outputs are distributed across a time-varying network. It is explained how to construct the local estimators which comprise the observer so that their state estimation errors all converge exponentially fast to zero at a fixed, but arbitrarily chosen rate provided the network's graph is strongly connected for all time. This is accomplished by exploiting several well-known properties of invariant subspaces plus several kinds of suitably defined matrix norms.

Mohsen Zamani, Uwe Helmke, Brian D. O. Anderson

This paper studies zeros of networked linear systems with time-invariant interconnection topology. While the characterization of zeros is given for both heterogeneous and homogeneous networks, homogeneous networks are explored in greater detail. In the current paper, for homogeneous networks with time-invariant interconnection dynamics, it is illustrated how the zeros of each individual agent's system description and zeros definable from the interconnection dynamics contribute to generating zeros of the whole network. We also demonstrate how zeros of networked systems and those of their associated blocked versions are related.

Bomin Jiang, Zhiyong Sun, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

Most current results on coverage control using mobile sensors require that one partitioned cell is associated with precisely one sensor. In this paper, we consider a class of coverage control problems involving higher order Voronoi partitions, motivated by applications where more than one sensor is required to monitor and cover one cell. Such applications are frequent in scenarios requiring the sensors to localize targets. We introduce a framework depending on a coverage performance function incorporating higher order Voronoi cells and then design a gradient-based controller which allows the multi-sensor system to achieve a local equilibrium in a distributed manner. The convergence properties are studied and related to Lloyd algorithm. We study also the extension to coverage of a discrete set of points. In addition, we provide a number of real world scenarios where our framework can be applied. Simulation results are also provided to show the controller performance.

Jingqiu Zhou, Wang Xuan, Shaoshuai Mou et al.

This paper proposes distributed algorithms for multi-agent networks to achieve a solution in finite time to a linear equation $Ax=b$ where $A$ has full row rank, and with the minimum $l_1$-norm in the underdetermined case (where $A$ has more columns than rows). The underlying network is assumed to be undirected and fixed, and an analytical proof is provided for the proposed algorithm to drive all agents' individual states to converge to a common value, viz a solution of $Ax=b$, which is the minimum $l_1$-norm solution in the underdetermined case. Numerical simulations are also provided as validation of the proposed algorithms.

Junfeng Wu, Guodong Shi, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

In this paper, we investigate probabilistic stability of Kalman filtering over fading channels modeled by $\ast$-mixing random processes, where channel fading is allowed to generate non-stationary packet dropouts with temporal and/or spatial correlations. Upper/lower almost sure (a.s.) stabilities and absolutely upper/lower a.s. stabilities are defined for characterizing the sample-path behaviors of the Kalman filtering. We prove that both upper and lower a.s. stabilities follow a zero-one law, i.e., these stabilities must happen with a probability either zero or one, and when the filtering system is one-step observable, the absolutely upper and lower a.s. stabilities can also be interpreted using a zero-one law. We establish general stability conditions for (absolutely) upper and lower a.s. stabilities. In particular, with one-step observability, we show the equivalence between absolutely a.s. stabilities and a.s. ones, and necessary and sufficient conditions in terms of packet arrival rate are derived; for the so-called non-degenerate systems, we also manage to give a necessary and sufficient condition for upper a.s. stability.

L. Wang, J. Liu, A. S. Morse et al.

A discrete-time modulus consensus model is considered in which the interaction among a family of networked agents is described by a time-dependent gain graph whose vertices correspond to agents and whose arcs are assigned complex numbers from a cyclic group. Limiting behavior of the model is studied using a graphical approach. It is shown that, under appropriate connectedness, a certain type of clustering will be reached exponentially fast for almost all initial conditions if and only if the sequence of gain graphs is "repeatedly jointly structurally balanced" corresponding to that type of clustering, where the number of clusters is at most the order of a cyclic group. It is also shown that the model will reach a consensus asymptotically at zero if the sequence of gain graphs is repeatedly jointly strongly connected and structurally unbalanced. In the special case when the cyclic group is of order two, the model simplifies to the so-called Altafini model whose gain graph is simply a signed graph.

Xuan Wang, Shaoshuai Mou, Brian. D. O. Anderson

This paper proposes a double-layered framework (or form of network) to integrate two mechanisms, termed consensus and conservation, achieving distributed solution of a linear equation. The multi-agent framework considered in the paper is composed of clusters (which serve as a form of aggregating agent) and each cluster consists of a sub-network of agents. By achieving consensus and conservation through agent-agent communications in the same cluster and cluster-cluster communications, distributed algorithms are devised for agents to cooperatively achieve a solution to the overall linear equation. These algorithms outperform existing consensus-based algorithms, including but not limited to the following aspects: first, each agent does not have to know as much as a complete row or column of the overall equation; second, each agent only needs to control as few as two scalar states when the number of clusters and the number of agents are sufficiently large; third, the dimensions of agents' states in the proposed algorithms do not have to be the same (while in contrast, algorithms based on the idea of standard consensus inherently require all agents' states to be of the same dimension). Both analytical proof and simulation results are provided to validate exponential convergence of the proposed distributed algorithms in solving linear equations.

Bomin Jiang, Brian D. O. Anderson, Hatem Hman

For a group of cooperating UAVs, localizing each other is often a key task. This paper studies the localization problem for a group of UAVs flying in 3D space with very limited information, i.e., when noisy distance measurements are the only type of inter-agent sensing that is available, and when only one UAV knows a global coordinate basis, the others being GPS-denied. Initially for a two-agent problem, but easily generalized to some multi-agent problems, constraints are established on the minimum number of required distance measurements required to achieve the localization. The paper also proposes an algorithm based on semidefinite programming (SDP), followed by maximum likelihood estimation using a gradient descent initialized from the SDP calculation. The efficacy of the algorithm is verified with experimental noisy flight data.

Zhiyong Sun, Marcus Greiff, Anders Robertsson et al.

We consider the problem of cooperative motion coordination for multiple heterogeneous mobile vehicles subject to various constraints. These include nonholonomic motion constraints, constant speed constraints, holonomic coordination constraints, and equality/inequality geometric constraints. We develop a general framework involving differential-algebraic equations and viability theory to determine coordination feasibility for a coordinated motion control under heterogeneous vehicle dynamics and different types of coordination task constraints. If a coordinated motion solution exists for the derived differential-algebraic equations and/or inequalities, a constructive algorithm is proposed to derive an equivalent dynamical system that generates a set of feasible coordinated motions for each individual vehicle. In case studies on coordinating two vehicles, we derive analytical solutions to motion generation for two-vehicle groups consisting of car-like vehicles, unicycle vehicles, or vehicles with constant speeds, which serve as benchmark coordination tasks for more complex vehicle groups. The motion generation algorithm is well-backed by simulation data for a wide variety of coordination situations involving heterogeneous vehicles. We then extend the vehicle control framework to deal with the cooperative coordination problem with time-varying coordination tasks and leader-follower structure. We show several simulation experiments on multi-vehicle coordination under various constraints to validate the theory and the effectiveness of the proposed schemes.

Zhiyong Sun, Qingchen Liu, Na Huang et al.

This paper discusses cooperative stabilization control of rigid formations via an event-based approach. We first design a centralized event-based formation control system, in which a central event controller determines the next triggering time and broadcasts the event signal to all the agents for control input update. We then build on this approach to propose a distributed event control strategy, in which each agent can use its local event trigger and local information to update the control input at its own event time. For both cases, the triggering condition, event function and triggering behavior are discussed in detail, and the exponential convergence of the event-based formation system is guaranteed.

Zhiyong Sun, Hector Garcia de Marina, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

This paper considers a collaborative tracking control problem using a group of fixed-wing unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) with constant and non-identical speeds. The dynamics of fixed-wing UAVs are modelled by unicycle-type equations with nonholonomic constraints, assuming that UAVs fly at constant altitudes in the nominal operation mode. The controller is designed such that all fixed-wing UAVs as a group can collaboratively track a desired target's position and velocity. We first present conditions on the relative speeds of tracking UAVs and the target to ensure that the tracking objective can be achieved when UAVs are subject to constant speed constraints. We construct a reference velocity that includes both the target's velocity and position as feedback, which is to be tracked by the group centroid. In this way, all vehicles' headings are controlled such that the group centroid follows a reference trajectory that successfully tracks the target's trajectory. A spacing controller is further devised to ensure that all vehicles stay close to the group centroid trajectory. Trade-offs in the controller design and performance limitations of the target tracking control due to the constant-speed constraint are also discussed in detail. Experimental results with three fixed-wing UAVs tracking a target rotorcraft are provided.

James S. Russell, Mengbin Ye, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

A GPS-denied UAV (Agent B) is localised through INS alignment with the aid of a nearby GPS-equipped UAV (Agent A), which broadcasts its position at several time instants. Agent B measures the signals' direction of arrival with respect to Agent B's inertial navigation frame. Semidefinite programming and the Orthogonal Procrustes algorithm are employed, and accuracy is improved through maximum likelihood estimation. The method is validated using flight data and simulations. A three-agent extension is explored.

Hector Garcia de Marina, Zhiyong Sun, Ming Cao et al.

In formation control, triangular formations consisting of three autonomous agents serve as a class of benchmarks that can be used to test and compare the performances of different controllers. We present an algorithm that combines the advantages of both position- and distance-based gradient descent control laws. For example, only two pairs of neighboring agents need to be controlled, agents can work in their own local frame of coordinates and the orientation of the formation with respect to a global frame of coordinates is not prescribed. We first present a novel technique based on adding artificial biases to neighboring agents' range sensors such that their eventual positions correspond to a collinear configuration. Right after, a small modification in the bias terms by introducing a prescribed rotation matrix will allow the control of the bearing of the neighboring agents.

James Russell, Mengbin Ye, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

This paper presents a novel approach for localising a GPS (Global Positioning System)-denied Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) with the aid of a GPS-equipped UAV in three-dimensional space. The GPS-equipped UAV makes discrete-time broadcasts of its global coordinates. The GPS-denied UAV simultaneously receives the broadcast and takes direction of arrival (DOA) measurements towards the origin of the broadcast in its local coordinate frame (obtained via an inertial navigation system (INS)). The aim is to determine the difference between the local and global frames, described by a rotation and a translation. In the noiseless case, global coordinates were recovered exactly by solving a system of linear equations. When DOA measurements are contaminated with noise, rank relaxed semidefinite programming (SDP) and the Orthogonal Procrustes algorithm are employed. Simulations are provided and factors affecting accuracy, such as noise levels and number of measurements, are explored.

Guodong Shi, Brian D. O. Anderson, U. Helmke

We study distributed network flows as solvers in continuous time for the linear algebraic equation $\mathbf{z}=\mathbf{H}\mathbf{y}$. Each node $i$ has access to a row $\mathbf{h}_i^{\rm T}$ of the matrix $\mathbf{H}$ and the corresponding entry $z_i$ in the vector $\mathbf{z}$. The first "consensus + projection" flow under investigation consists of two terms, one from standard consensus dynamics and the other contributing to projection onto each affine subspace specified by the $\mathbf{h}_i$ and $z_i$. The second "projection consensus" flow on the other hand simply replaces the relative state feedback in consensus dynamics with projected relative state feedback. Without dwell-time assumption on switching graphs as well as without positively lower bounded assumption on arc weights, we prove that all node states converge to a common solution of the linear algebraic equation, if there is any. The convergence is global for the "consensus + projection" flow while local for the "projection consensus" flow in the sense that the initial values must lie on the affine subspaces. If the linear equation has no exact solutions, we show that the node states can converge to a ball around the least squares solution whose radius can be made arbitrarily small through selecting a sufficiently large gain for the "consensus + projection" flow under fixed bidirectional graphs. Semi-global convergence to approximate least squares solutions is demonstrated for general switching directed graphs under suitable conditions. It is also shown that the "projection consensus" flow drives the average of the node states to the least squares solution with complete graph. Numerical examples are provided as illustrations of the established results.

Brian D. O. Anderson, Guodong Shi, Jochen Trumpf

We study continuous-time consensus dynamics for multi-agent systems with undirected switching interaction graphs. We establish a necessary and sufficient condition for exponential asymptotic consensus based on the classical theory of complete observability. The proof is remarkably simple compared to similar results in the literature and the conditions for consensus are mild. This observability-based method can also be applied to the case where negatively weighted edges are present. Additionally, as a by-product of the observability based arguments, we show that the nodes' initial value can be recovered from the signals on the edges up to a shift of the network average.

Brian D. O. Anderson, Shaoshuai Mou, A. Stephen Morse et al.

The paper develops a technique for solving a linear equation $Ax=b$ with a square and nonsingular matrix $A$, using a decentralized gradient algorithm. In the language of control theory, there are $n$ agents, each storing at time $t$ an $n$-vector, call it $x_i(t)$, and a graphical structure associating with each agent a vertex of a fixed, undirected and connected but otherwise arbitrary graph $\mathcal G$ with vertex set and edge set $\mathcal V$ and $\mathcal E$ respectively. We provide differential equation update laws for the $x_i$ with the property that each $x_i$ converges to the solution of the linear equation exponentially fast. The equation for $x_i$ includes additive terms weighting those $x_j$ for which vertices in $\mathcal G$ corresponding to the $i$-th and $j$-th agents are adjacent. The results are extended to the case where $A$ is not square but has full row rank, and bounds are given on the convergence rate.

Junfeng Wu, Guodong Shi, Brian D. O. Anderson et al.

This paper investigates the stability of Kalman filtering over Gilbert-Elliott channels where random packet drop follows a time-homogeneous two-state Markov chain whose state transition is determined by a pair of failure and recovery rates. First of all, we establish a relaxed condition guaranteeing peak-covariance stability described by an inequality in terms of the spectral radius of the system matrix and transition probabilities of the Markov chain. We further show that that condition can be interpreted using a linear matrix inequality feasibility problem. Next, we prove that the peak-covariance stability implies mean-square stability, if the system matrix has no defective eigenvalues on the unit circle. This connection between the two stability notions holds for any random packet drop process. We prove that there exists a critical curve in the failure-recovery rate plane, below which the Kalman filter is mean-square stable and no longer mean-square stable above, via a coupling method in stochastic processes. Finally, a lower bound for this critical failure rate is obtained making use of the relationship we establish between the two stability criteria, based on an approximate relaxation of the system matrix.