Models in the Loop: Aiding Crowdworkers with Generative Annotation Assistants
This work addresses the efficiency problem in adversarial data collection for machine learning practitioners, offering a cost-effective method to maintain robustness gains.
The paper tackles the high cost of Dynamic Adversarial Data Collection (DADC) by introducing Generative Annotation Assistants (GAAs), which provide real-time suggestions to annotators, resulting in over a 30% annotation speed-up and over a 5x improvement in model fooling rates.
In Dynamic Adversarial Data Collection (DADC), human annotators are tasked with finding examples that models struggle to predict correctly. Models trained on DADC-collected training data have been shown to be more robust in adversarial and out-of-domain settings, and are considerably harder for humans to fool. However, DADC is more time-consuming than traditional data collection and thus more costly per annotated example. In this work, we examine whether we can maintain the advantages of DADC, without incurring the additional cost. To that end, we introduce Generative Annotation Assistants (GAAs), generator-in-the-loop models that provide real-time suggestions that annotators can either approve, modify, or reject entirely. We collect training datasets in twenty experimental settings and perform a detailed analysis of this approach for the task of extractive question answering (QA) for both standard and adversarial data collection. We demonstrate that GAAs provide significant efficiency benefits with over a 30% annotation speed-up, while leading to over a 5x improvement in model fooling rates. In addition, we find that using GAA-assisted training data leads to higher downstream model performance on a variety of question answering tasks over adversarial data collection.