PMC-Patients: A Large-scale Dataset of Patient Summaries and Relations for Benchmarking Retrieval-based Clinical Decision Support Systems
This addresses the problem of limited data for developing ReCDS systems, which can aid clinical workflows, but it is incremental as it primarily provides a new dataset and benchmarks rather than a novel method.
The authors tackled the lack of diverse patient collections and large-scale annotation datasets for Retrieval-based Clinical Decision Support (ReCDS) by creating PMC-Patients, a dataset with 167k patient summaries, 3.1M patient-article relevance annotations, and 293k patient-patient similarity annotations, which they used to benchmark ReCDS tasks and show it is challenging for existing methods.
Objective: Retrieval-based Clinical Decision Support (ReCDS) can aid clinical workflow by providing relevant literature and similar patients for a given patient. However, the development of ReCDS systems has been severely obstructed by the lack of diverse patient collections and publicly available large-scale patient-level annotation datasets. In this paper, we aim to define and benchmark two ReCDS tasks: Patient-to-Article Retrieval (ReCDS-PAR) and Patient-to-Patient Retrieval (ReCDS-PPR) using a novel dataset called PMC-Patients. Methods: We extract patient summaries from PubMed Central articles using simple heuristics and utilize the PubMed citation graph to define patient-article relevance and patient-patient similarity. We also implement and evaluate several ReCDS systems on the PMC-Patients benchmarks, including sparse retrievers, dense retrievers, and nearest neighbor retrievers. We conduct several case studies to show the clinical utility of PMC-Patients. Results: PMC-Patients contains 167k patient summaries with 3.1M patient-article relevance annotations and 293k patient-patient similarity annotations, which is the largest-scale resource for ReCDS and also one of the largest patient collections. Human evaluation and analysis show that PMC-Patients is a diverse dataset with high-quality annotations. The evaluation of various ReCDS systems shows that the PMC-Patients benchmark is challenging and calls for further research. Conclusion: We present PMC-Patients, a large-scale, diverse, and publicly available patient summary dataset with the largest-scale patient-level relation annotations. Based on PMC-Patients, we formally define two benchmark tasks for ReCDS systems and evaluate various existing retrieval methods. PMC-Patients can largely facilitate methodology research on ReCDS systems and shows real-world clinical utility.