AIApr 1, 2022

Symbolic Search for Optimal Planning with Expressive Extensions

arXiv:2204.00288v14 citationsh-index: 8
Originality Synthesis-oriented
AI Analysis

This work addresses limitations in domain-independent planning for AI agents by enabling native support for expressive features, though it appears incremental as it builds on existing symbolic search approaches.

The thesis tackles the problem of optimal planning with expressive extensions in classical planning, which are often unsupported by existing planners, by proposing symbolic search methods and showing that symbolic blind search performs on par with state-of-the-art strategies.

In classical planning, the goal is to derive a course of actions that allows an intelligent agent to move from any situation it finds itself in to one that satisfies its goals. Classical planning is considered domain-independent, i.e., it is not limited to a particular application and can be used to solve different types of reasoning problems. In practice, however, some properties of a planning problem at hand require an expressive extension of the standard classical planning formalism to capture and model them. Although the importance of many of these extensions is well known, most planners, especially optimal planners, do not support these extended planning formalisms. The lack of support not only limits the use of these planners for certain problems, but even if it is possible to model the problems without these extensions, it often leads to increased effort in modeling or makes modeling practically impossible as the required problem encoding size increases exponentially. In this thesis, we propose to use symbolic search for cost-optimal planning for different expressive extensions of classical planning, all capturing different aspects of the problem. In particular, we study planning with axioms, planning with state-dependent action costs, oversubscription planning, and top-k planning. For all formalisms, we present complexity and compilability results, highlighting that it is desirable and even necessary to natively support the corresponding features. We analyze symbolic heuristic search and show that the search performance does not always benefit from the use of a heuristic and that the search performance can exponentially deteriorate even under the best possible circumstances, namely the perfect heuristic. This reinforces that symbolic blind search is the dominant symbolic search strategy nowadays, on par with other state-of-the-art cost-optimal planning strategies...

Foundations

The foundational work for this paper's niche, ranked by how specifically the neighbourhood builds on it — not by global fame.

Your Notes