AILOAug 31, 2022

Proportoids

arXiv:2210.01751v75 citationsh-index: 3
AI Analysis

This work addresses foundational mathematical theory for analogical reasoning, which is incremental in building on prior axiomatic traditions.

The paper tackles the problem of formalizing analogical proportions by introducing 'proportoids' as sets with a 4-ary relation and studying proportion-preserving mappings, contributing to the mathematical foundations of analogical reasoning.

Analogical proportions are expressions of the form ``$a$ is to $b$ what $c$ is to $d$'' at the core of analogical reasoning. This paper contributes to the mathematical foundations of analogical proportions in the axiomatic tradition as initiated -- in the tradition of the ancient Greeks -- by Yves Lepage two decades ago. More precisely, we first introduce the name ``proportoid'' for sets endowed with a 4-ary analogical proportion relation satisfying a suitable set of axioms. We then study study different kinds of proportion-preserving mappings and relations and their properties. Formally, we define homomorphisms of proportoids as mappings $\mathsf H$ satisfying $a:b::c:d$ iff $\mathsf Ha:\mathsf Hb::\mathsf Hc:\mathsf Hd$ for all elements and show that their kernel is a congruence. Moreover, we introduce (proportional) analogies as mappings $\mathsf A$ satisfying $a:b::\mathsf Aa:\mathsf Ab$ for all elements $a$ and $b$ in the source domain and show how to compute partial analogies. We then introduce a number of useful relations between functions (including homomorphisms and analogies) on proportoids and study their properties. In a broader sense, this paper is a further step towards a mathematical theory of analogical proportions.

Foundations

The foundational work for this paper's niche, ranked by how specifically the neighbourhood builds on it — not by global fame.

Your Notes