The Missing Parts: Augmenting Fact Verification with Half-Truth Detection
This addresses the issue of misinformation from omitted information in political claims, enhancing trustworthiness in fact-checking, though it is incremental as it builds on existing pipelines.
The paper tackles the problem of fact verification systems struggling with half-truths, which are factually correct but misleading due to omitted context, by introducing a new benchmark and a modular framework that improves Half-True classification F1 by up to 16 points.
Fact verification systems typically assess whether a claim is supported by retrieved evidence, assuming that truthfulness depends solely on what is stated. However, many real-world claims are half-truths, factually correct yet misleading due to the omission of critical context. Existing models struggle with such cases, as they are not designed to reason about omitted information. We introduce the task of half-truth detection, and propose PolitiFact-Hidden, a new benchmark with 15k political claims annotated with sentence-level evidence alignment and inferred claim intent. To address this challenge, we present TRACER, a modular re-assessment framework that identifies omission-based misinformation by aligning evidence, inferring implied intent, and estimating the causal impact of hidden content. TRACER can be integrated into existing fact-checking pipelines and consistently improves performance across multiple strong baselines. Notably, it boosts Half-True classification F1 by up to 16 points, highlighting the importance of modeling omissions for trustworthy fact verification. The benchmark and code are available via https://github.com/tangyixuan/TRACER.