The Principles of Human-like Conscious Machine
This addresses the attribution problem in consciousness studies for philosophers, cognitive scientists, and AI researchers, offering a potential path toward human-like AI beyond current statistics-based approaches.
The paper tackles the problem of determining whether AI systems possess phenomenal consciousness by proposing a substrate-independent, logically rigorous sufficiency criterion for consciousness, arguing that machines meeting this criterion should be regarded as conscious with confidence comparable to attributing consciousness to humans, and showing that humans themselves can be viewed as satisfying this framework.
Determining whether another system, biological or artificial, possesses phenomenal consciousness has long been a central challenge in consciousness studies. This attribution problem has become especially pressing with the rise of large language models and other advanced AI systems, where debates about "AI consciousness" implicitly rely on some criterion for deciding whether a given system is conscious. In this paper, we propose a substrate-independent, logically rigorous, and counterfeit-resistant sufficiency criterion for phenomenal consciousness. We argue that any machine satisfying this criterion should be regarded as conscious with at least the same level of confidence with which we attribute consciousness to other humans. Building on this criterion, we develop a formal framework and specify a set of operational principles that guide the design of systems capable of meeting the sufficiency condition. We further argue that machines engineered according to this framework can, in principle, realize phenomenal consciousness. As an initial validation, we show that humans themselves can be viewed as machines that satisfy this framework and its principles. If correct, this proposal carries significant implications for philosophy, cognitive science, and artificial intelligence. It offers an explanation for why certain qualia, such as the experience of red, are in principle irreducible to physical description, while simultaneously providing a general reinterpretation of human information processing. Moreover, it suggests a path toward a new paradigm of AI beyond current statistics-based approaches, potentially guiding the construction of genuinely human-like AI.