nnActive: A Framework for Evaluation of Active Learning in 3D Biomedical Segmentation
This work addresses the problem of reducing annotation costs for 3D biomedical segmentation, which is crucial for researchers and practitioners in medical imaging, but it is incremental as it builds on existing AL methods and focuses on improving evaluation rather than introducing a new paradigm.
The paper tackled the lack of consensus on whether Active Learning (AL) consistently outperforms Random sampling in 3D biomedical segmentation by introducing nnActive, a framework that addresses evaluation pitfalls; results showed that while AL methods outperform standard Random sampling, none reliably surpass an improved Foreground Aware Random sampling, with Predictive Entropy being the best-performing method but requiring more annotation effort.
Semantic segmentation is crucial for various biomedical applications, yet its reliance on large annotated datasets presents a bottleneck due to the high cost and specialized expertise required for manual labeling. Active Learning (AL) aims to mitigate this challenge by querying only the most informative samples, thereby reducing annotation effort. However, in the domain of 3D biomedical imaging, there is no consensus on whether AL consistently outperforms Random sampling. Four evaluation pitfalls hinder the current methodological assessment. These are (1) restriction to too few datasets and annotation budgets, (2) using 2D models on 3D images without partial annotations, (3) Random baseline not being adapted to the task, and (4) measuring annotation cost only in voxels. In this work, we introduce nnActive, an open-source AL framework that overcomes these pitfalls by (1) means of a large scale study spanning four biomedical imaging datasets and three label regimes, (2) extending nnU-Net by using partial annotations for training with 3D patch-based query selection, (3) proposing Foreground Aware Random sampling strategies tackling the foreground-background class imbalance of medical images and (4) propose the foreground efficiency metric, which captures the low annotation cost of background-regions. We reveal the following findings: (A) while all AL methods outperform standard Random sampling, none reliably surpasses an improved Foreground Aware Random sampling; (B) benefits of AL depend on task specific parameters; (C) Predictive Entropy is overall the best performing AL method, but likely requires the most annotation effort; (D) AL performance can be improved with more compute intensive design choices. As a holistic, open-source framework, nnActive can serve as a catalyst for research and application of AL in 3D biomedical imaging. Code is at: https://github.com/MIC-DKFZ/nnActive