Isolating Recurring Execution-Dependent Abnormal Patterns on NISQ Quantum Devices
For quantum computing practitioners, QRisk provides a method to improve circuit fidelity on NISQ devices by learning from recurring execution-dependent errors.
QRisk discovers backend-specific abnormal patterns in quantum circuits that cause excess error not captured by noise models, and disrupts them via commuting gate swaps, reducing excess hardware noise by 24% on ibm_fez and 45% on ibm_marrakesh.
Quantum compilers rely on calibration-derived noise models to guide circuit mapping and optimization. These models characterize gate and qubit errors independently and miss context-dependent effects such as crosstalk and correlated scheduling errors. As a result, two compiled circuits that score equally under the noise model can behave very differently on real hardware, and the compiler has no mechanism to learn from such recurring mismatches. We present QRisk, a framework that discovers backend-specific abnormal patterns from real hardware executions. QRisk uses delta debugging to isolate compact circuit fragments that consistently produce excess error not predicted by the noise model, then validates their persistence across repeated runs and calibration windows. The verified patterns are stored in a backend-specific pattern database. At compilation time, QRisk scans a compiled circuit for occurrences of known patterns and applies targeted commuting gate swaps to disrupt them, producing a semantically equivalent circuit with fewer abnormal patterns. We evaluate QRisk on two IBM backends (ibm_fez and ibm_marrakesh) using Grover search circuits. On both backends, discovered patterns persist across multiple calibration windows over months. Disrupting these patterns via commuting gate swaps reduces excess hardware noise by 24% on ibm_fez (Spearman $ρ$ = 0.515, p = 0.0007) and 45% on ibm_marrakesh ($ρ$ = 0.711, p < 0.0001), while the noise model predicts identical error for all equivalent circuits. Testing on a third backend confirms that these patterns are backend-specific.