Where Does Texture Evidence Live in SAM? Features, Proposal Masks, and Texture Segmentation
This work decomposes SAM's failure on texture segmentation into representation, proposal, readout, and commitment issues, providing a diagnostic framework for foundation models applied to non-object-centric tasks.
The paper investigates whether frozen SAM (Segment Anything Model) contains texture-relevant evidence for texture segmentation, finding that while SAM fails by default, its features preserve texture organization and proposal banks contain texture-aligned masks, with failure modes varying by scene complexity.
Texture segmentation stresses foundation segmentation because meaningful regions are defined by material or repeated appearance rather than object identity. Segment Anything Models (SAMs) often fail by default on such texture-defined partitions, but this failure is ambiguous: the texture evidence may be absent, missing from the proposal bank, or present but selected or assembled incorrectly by an object-centric readout. We ask what texture-relevant evidence is already preserved in frozen SAM before adaptation. We study two frozen evidence spaces: multiscale features, probed with a minimal clustering readout, and the automatic proposal bank, treated as evidence for a supervised consolidation readout. SAM is frozen throughout; we do not fine-tune the backbone or retrain the proposal generator. Across RWTD, STLD, an ADE20K-selected refined-crop complement, and a ControlNet-stitched PTD bridge archive, frozen SAM is not a texture segmenter by default, but its failures are not simple texture blindness. Coarse frozen features preserve texture organization, and proposal banks often contain texture-aligned masks or fragments. Natural scenes more often require assembly and commitment over fragments, while cleaner synthetic cases more often reduce to selecting an already coherent proposal. Default mask failure should therefore be decomposed into representation evidence, proposal-bank support, readout mismatch, and commitment failure.