Evaluating Affective Objectives: Statistical Numbing in Data Visualization
For visualization designers, this study provides empirical evidence that human-driven narratives can increase prosocial behavior, but mixing data with human stories may reduce it, challenging common design assumptions.
The paper investigates how different narrative strategies (data-driven, human-driven, or mixed) in data visualizations affect prosocial behavior, measured by donations. The human-driven narrative (photographs and stories of individuals) elicited the highest donations, while the mixed narrative led to the lowest.
Visualizations can help audiences understand the scale of tragedies, such as the consequences of natural disasters, war, genocide, and pandemics. In these cases, a visualization designer's default behavior may be to focus on communicating quantitative information: numbers, statistics, and trends. However, this may not reflect higher-level affective objectives to inspire their audience to care about an issue, empathize with others, or take action to help those in need. Worse, standard visualizations may conflict with these goals, as statistics can numb emotions and reduce prosocial feelings toward people in need. Designers have developed strategies to increase affective responses through data visualizations, such as blending data narratives and personal narratives about individuals. In this paper, we explore three design strategies for communicating a humanitarian crisis: data-driven, human-driven, or mixed narratives. We conducted an empirical study to explore the effect of statistical numbing in the context of these types of narratives in the format of data videos. In particular, we measure prosocial feelings and behaviors by giving participants the option of donating money as part of the study. We find that human-driven narratives (photographs and stories of individuals) elicited the highest donations and that the mixed narrative combination led to the lowest donations. We discuss the limitations of this study and the implications of pursuing affective objectives and the numbing of empathy in data visualization design.