Spanning Paths and Cycles: Structural Limitations of the Irrelevant Vertex Technique
This work provides a precise combinatorial characterization of the limits of a fundamental technique in algorithmic graph theory, resolving a key question for spanning routing problems.
The paper identifies a structural parameter called depth_2 that determines exactly when the Irrelevant Vertex Technique can solve the Spanning Disjoint Paths problem. They prove a complete dichotomy: the technique works if and only if the annotated graph class has bounded depth_2, and provide an algorithm with runtime 2^{2^{poly(k+d)}}·n^2.
The Irrelevant Vertex Technique is one of the cornerstones of algorithmic graph theory, underlying Robertson and Seymour's algorithm for \textsc{Disjoint Paths} and much of the algorithmic Graph Minors theory. We show that, in the setting of spanning routing, this technique exhibits an exact combinatorial limitation. Unlike classical routing problems, spanning routing is not governed by the number of distinguished vertices but by the way they are distributed throughout the graph. The input is a triple $(G,R,\mathcal{T})$ where $(G,R)$ is an annotated graph and $\mathcal{T}$ is a set of terminal pairs. The goal is to determine if $G$ contains a family of internally disjoint paths connecting the pairs in $\mathcal{T}$ such that the union of the paths spans the set $R$. We identify a new structural parameter of annotated graphs, called $\mathsf{depth}_2$, that measures precisely this phenomenon. Our main result is a complete combinatorial dichotomy: for every red-minor-closed class of annotated graphs, the Irrelevant Vertex Technique applies to \textsc{Spanning Disjoint Paths} \textsl{if and only if} the class has bounded $\mathsf{depth}_2$. Thus $\mathsf{depth}_2$ forms the exact structural boundary between classes where the Robertson-Seymour paradigm survives and those where it breaks down. Our proof combines a new local structure theorem for annotated graphs of bounded $\mathsf{depth}_2$ with a spanning analogue of the celebrated Vital Linkage Theorem. The resulting algorithm solves \textsc{Spanning Disjoint Paths} in time $2^{2^{\mathbf{poly}(k+d)}}\cdot n^2$ where $d$ is the $\mathsf{depth}_2$ of the input instance. We provide matching lower bounds showing that beyond bounded $\mathsf{depth}_2$ no irrelevant-vertex rule can exist, even on planar graphs. In particular, $\mathsf{depth}_2$ is the exact combinatorial barrier for the Irrelevant Vertex Technique under spanning constraints.