SliceGraph: Mapping Process Isomers in Multi-Run Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
For researchers studying chain-of-thought reasoning, this work reveals that multiple distinct reasoning paths can lead to the same correct answer, challenging the common practice of aggregating only final answers.
SliceGraph maps process isomers in multi-run chain-of-thought reasoning, revealing that correct trajectories with the same answer often split into multiple process families (85.5% of 954 problem-model cells) with 76.6% cross-family run pairs, showing that final-answer aggregation overlooks structured multi-route process geometry.
Multi-run chain-of-thought reasoning is usually collapsed to final-answer aggregates, which discard howsampled trajectories share, split, and rejoin through intermediate computation. We propose SliceGraph, a post-hoc problem-model-cell graph built by mutual-kNN over sparse activation-key Jaccard similarity between CoT slices, and treat it as a measurement object for process geometry rather than as a decoding program. Across sampled CoT ensembles from three primary 4B/8B models on math and science benchmarks, blinded annotation supports SliceGraph biconnected components as shared reasoning-state units and process families as within-family strategy-coherent route units. In 85.5% of 954 problem-model cells, correct CoTs sharing the same normalized answer split into multiple process families; among cells with at least two such runs, 76.6% of run pairs are cross-family on average. We call such same-answer, family-divergent correct trajectories process isomers. A label-seeded reward field provides a separate value-landscape layer: success-associated regions often split into disconnected high-value cores, and route families specialize over these core footprints rather than merely duplicating one another. A typed-state transition analysis further shows that process families navigate the same atlas with distinct transition kernels under matched null controls. Representation ablations, a cross-architecture replication, and two cross-scale replications support the robustness of the route-family scaffold, showing that final-answer aggregation overlooks this structured multi-route process geometry.